
REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
COURT OF CASSATION
2nd CIVIL CHAMBER
FILE NO.: 2016/17354
DECISION NO.: 2018/5391
DATE OF DECISION: 24.04.2018
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE: Family Court
TYPE OF ACTION: Divorce
THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE CHILD ARE PARAMOUNT IN DETERMINING CUSTODY.
At the conclusion of the proceedings between the parties, the judgment rendered by the local court, the date and number of which are indicated above, was appealed by the defendant husband. Upon reading the documents, the matter was duly considered and deliberated:
1- In view of the contents of the file, the evidence on which the judgment is based, the reasons consistent with the law, and particularly the fact that although the action was accepted pursuant to Article 166/1 of the Turkish Civil Code, the reference in the judgment to Article 166/3 constitutes a clerical error, the appeal objections of the defendant husband, except for those falling within the scope of the following paragraph, are unfounded.
2- The custody of the parties’ joint children, …, born in 2004, and …, born in 2008, was awarded to the claimant mother by the Court. The paramount consideration in determining custody is the best interests of the children. Pursuant to Article 5 of Law No. 4787 on the Establishment, Duties and Trial Procedures of Family Courts, an examination should have been conducted and a report obtained from the experts consisting of a psychologist, a pedagogist, and a social worker assigned to the Family Court, by interviewing both parents and the children; it should have been investigated, taking into consideration the parties’ housing, income, social and psychological circumstances, whether either parent had any circumstances preventing them from assuming custody in a manner conducive to the children’s healthy development; the children who have reached the age of discernment should have been heard and their opinions obtained; and, taking into consideration the other evidence, it should have been determined with which parent it would be in the children’s best interests to reside, and a decision regarding custody should have been rendered accordingly.
Instead, the Court rendered its judgment concerning custody on the basis of an incomplete examination and investigation. This is contrary to procedural law and the applicable law and therefore requires reversal.
CONCLUSION: For the reason set forth in paragraph 2 above, the judgment under appeal is hereby REVERSED. In light of the ground for reversal, there is no need at this stage to examine the appeal objections concerning child support. The remaining portions of the judgment subject to appeal, which fall outside the scope of the reversal, are hereby AFFIRMED for the reason set forth in paragraph 1 above. Upon request, the advance appeal fee shall be refunded to the party who paid it. An application for correction of the decision may be made within 15 days from the date of service of this decision. It was unanimously decided on 24.04.2018.