Anasayfa » Blog » Testimony Among Individuals Who Have Filed Lawsuits Against Their Employers Is Admissible: Supreme Court Ruling

Testimony Among Individuals Who Have Filed Lawsuits Against Their Employers Is Admissible: Supreme Court Ruling

Eviction Of The Workplace Due To Necessity Supreme Court Decision

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
COURT OF CASSATION
7th CIVIL CHAMBER
FILE NO.: 2014/15057
DECISION NO.: 2014/19544
DATE OF DECISION: 27.10.2014

TESTIMONY GIVEN BY PERSONS WHO HAVE FILED LAWSUITS AGAINST THE EMPLOYER IN FAVOR OF ONE ANOTHER IS VALID.

CASE: Upon the request of the attorneys for the claimant and the defendant Ç. Çimento San. ve Tic. A.Ş. for the examination by the Court of Cassation of the judgment rendered as a result of the proceedings between the parties, it was understood that the appeal request was filed within the prescribed period. The file was examined and the matter was duly considered.

DECISION:

1-) In view of the contents of the file, the legal and juridical grounds of the judgment, which have also been adopted by our Chamber, the material evidence on which the judgment is based, and particularly the absence of any error in the assessment of such evidence, all appeal objections of the defendant Ç. Çimento San. ve Tic. A.Ş., as well as the claimant’s appeal objections other than those falling within the scope of the following paragraph, are hereby dismissed.

2-) The claimant requested payment of severance and notice pay, as well as certain employment receivables, on the grounds that while working as a mixer operator at the defendant’s workplace, his employment contract had been unjustly terminated by the employer.

The defendant Ç. Çimento San. ve Tic. A.Ş. argued that the claimant’s employment contract had been terminated by the other defendant company, that, as the contracting authority, it had paid all receivables for which it was responsible, and that no claim could be directed against it. The other defendant, O. Hazır Beton Nak. İnş. Pet. Ür. Hayv. Tur. Oto. San. ve Tic. A.Ş., argued that the employment contract had been terminated for a justified reason due to the completion of the tender, that no receivables remained outstanding, and requested dismissal of the action.

The Court of First Instance partially accepted the action on the ground that the claimant had terminated his employment contract for a justified reason.

There is a dispute between the parties as to by whom the employment contract was terminated and whether such termination was based on a justified reason.

In the present case, the claimant requested severance and notice pay and other employment receivables on the grounds that his employment contract had been terminated by the defendant without a justified reason and that his wages had not been paid. The expert who prepared a report in the file concluded, relying on the petition dated 15.1.2013 addressed to the defendant Ç. Çimento San. ve Tic. Anonim Şirketi, which had been submitted to the file and whose signature had not been denied by the claimant, that the claimant had justifiably terminated his employment contract on 15.01.2013 due to the non-payment of his wages and that, although he was entitled to severance pay, he could not claim notice pay. The Court, relying on this report, dismissed the claim for notice pay. However, the judgment rendered is erroneous.

In comparable cases in which petitions containing an identical or substantially similar declaration of termination by the claimant were submitted to the file, although the claimant had submitted a resignation petition dated 15/01/2013, it was determined that the resignation petition did not reflect the employee’s true will; that the employee had written the resignation petition after being told by the employer that his wage receivables would be paid; and that, considering the statements of the claimant and defendant witnesses and the written response of Ç. A.Ş., as well as the fact that the contract between Ç. and the defendant O. Ltd. Şti. had ended on 15/01/2013, the employee had no legal interest in resigning on the date on which the contract between the defendants ended. It was further established from the series of cases filed before our Court that the employees who had been collectively dismissed had written the same resignation petition in their own handwriting. On these grounds, the employees’ claims for severance and notice pay were accepted on the basis that their employment contracts had been unjustly and without notice terminated by the employer, and these judgments and the grounds for termination were upheld by our Chamber and became final. In view of this situation, since it is understood that the claimant’s employment contract was terminated by the defendant O. Hazır Beton Nak. İnş. Pet. Ür. Hayv. Tur. Oto. San.ve Tic. A.Ş. without a justified reason, it was erroneous to dismiss the claimant’s claim for notice pay, which should also have been accepted, and this constitutes a ground for reversal.

3-) With regard to the claimant’s employment wage receivables, the Court held that the witnesses heard at the claimant’s request, Y. D. and Y. A., had ongoing lawsuits before the court concerning the same subject matter; that the claimant and the witnesses had testified in favor of one another concerning working hours; and that, considering that they were adverse to the defendant, their testimony could not be relied upon. Accordingly, the Court dismissed the claimant’s claims on the ground that, based also on the statements of the defendant’s witnesses, the claimant had not worked overtime, on weekends, or on public holidays.

The claimant and his witnesses are persons who performed the same work at the same workplace, under the same working conditions, and who suffered the same type of harm. Therefore, it is entirely natural that they filed lawsuits based on the same claims. Moreover, apart from these witnesses, all employees working on the aforementioned HES project filed lawsuits based on the same claims. This circumstance does not demonstrate that their testimony is invalid; rather, it demonstrates that they experienced the same difficulties. If such testimony is not given credence, the claimant has no reasonable opportunity to find witnesses who have knowledge of the workplace conditions. Furthermore, according to the general principles of labor law, it is the defendant who must prove that the claimant’s wage receivables were paid. Given that it is established by the contents of the file that the claimant worked overtime, worked on national holidays and general public holidays other than religious holidays, and worked on weekly rest days, but that the defendant did not pay the corresponding amounts, the claimant’s claims concerning wage receivables should also have been accepted, as in the comparable cases. The dismissal of these claims was therefore erroneous and constitutes a ground for reversal.

Accordingly, the appeal objections of the claimant’s attorney directed to these matters should be accepted and the judgment should be reversed.

CONCLUSION: For the reasons set forth above, the judgment under appeal is hereby REVERSED; the appeal fee paid in advance shall, upon request, be refunded to the claimant; the appeal fee set forth below shall be imposed upon the defendant; and it was unanimously decided on 27.10.2014.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir