Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Ruling on Abuse of Trust in the Course of Business,, and Forgery of a Private Document

Supreme Court Ruling on Abuse of Trust in the Course of Business,, and Forgery of a Private Document

Joint Custody And Its Scope

Summary:

It was found that there was no evidence, free from any reasonable doubt and sufficient to establish a conviction, demonstrating that the defendant, who worked as an accountant at ……………. Sanayi ve Ticareti Ltd. Şti., owned by the complainant, committed the offense of breach of trust due to his service by taking the TRY 6,500 given to him by the complainant for the purpose of paying the company’s debts and then disappearing. Accordingly, there was no error in the court’s finding that the defendant should be acquitted.

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
Court of Cassation
15th Criminal Chamber

Case No.: 2013/19113
Decision No.: 2015/32092
Decision Date: [Not stated]

The judgment acquitting the defendant of the offense of breach of trust due to his service, as well as the judgments convicting the defendant of the offenses of qualified fraud and forgery of a private document, having been appealed by the Public Prosecutor of the locality with respect to the acquittal and by counsel for the defendant with respect to the convictions, the case file was examined and the following was considered:

It was found that there was no evidence, free from any reasonable doubt and sufficient to establish a conviction, demonstrating that the defendant, who worked as an accountant at ……………………… Sanayi ve Ticareti Ltd. Şti., owned by the complainant, committed the offense of breach of trust due to his service by taking the TRY 6,500 given to him by the complainant for the purpose of paying the company’s debts and then disappearing. Accordingly, there was no error in the finding that the defendant should be acquitted.

With respect to the offense of qualified fraud, considering that the unjust benefit obtained amounted to TRY 5,500.00, the imposition of 275 days of judicial fine instead of 550 days when calculating twice the amount of the benefit resulted in an insufficient sentence. However, since there was no appeal against the defendant’s interests on this issue, it was not considered a ground for reversal.

With regard to paragraphs (1), (2), and (4) of Article 53 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, the partial annulment decision rendered by the Constitutional Court on 08.10.2015, numbered E.2014/140 and K.2015/85, having been published in the Official Gazette on 24.11.2015 and thereby entering into force, it was deemed possible to take the said decision into consideration at the enforcement stage, provided that the relevant conditions are satisfied.

At the conclusion of the proceedings, since the court reached its finding and assessment on the grounds that it had not been established that the offense of breach of trust due to service had been committed by the defendant, the appellate objections of the Public Prosecutor of the locality requesting that the defendant be convicted of the charged offense, as well as the appellate objections of counsel for the defendant alleging that the statutory elements of the offenses of qualified fraud and forgery of a private document had not been established, are hereby REJECTED, and, in accordance with the request, the judgments are AFFIRMED.

It was unanimously decided on 10.12.2015.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir