Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Decision on the Rule of Special Jurisdiction for Alimony Cases

Supreme Court Decision on the Rule of Special Jurisdiction for Alimony Cases

Joint Custody And Its Scope

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE

COURT OF CASSATION
12th CIVIL CHAMBER

File No.: 2016/26097
Decision No.: 2018/333
Date of Decision: 18.01.2018

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE: Enforcement Court

Upon the request of the creditor for appellate review within the prescribed period of the court decision bearing the date and number indicated above, the relevant case file was sent from the local court to the Chamber. After hearing the report prepared by Reviewing Judge … concerning the case file and reading and examining all documents contained therein, the matter was duly considered and deliberated:

In the non-judicial enforcement proceeding through general attachment proceedings initiated by the creditor on the basis of the interim decision awarding temporary alimony rendered in the divorce case file numbered 2010/567 E. of the … 2nd Civil Court of First Instance, following service of the payment order in Form No. 7, the debtor applied to the enforcement office within the statutory period and, together with objecting to the debt, also objected to the jurisdiction of the … Enforcement Offices, asserting that the competent enforcement office was the … Enforcement Office, where the debtor’s place of residence was located. Thereupon, the creditor applied to the Enforcement Court and requested the removal of the debtor’s objections. The Court dismissed the creditor’s request for the removal of the objection on the ground that the interim decision awarding temporary alimony, which constituted the basis of the enforcement proceeding, was neither a judgment nor a document deemed equivalent to a judgment under Article 38 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, and therefore the debtor’s objection to jurisdiction was justified.

Article 177 of the Turkish Civil Code provides that, “In alimony actions to be brought after divorce, the court of the place of residence of the alimony creditor shall have jurisdiction.” Accordingly, a special alternative jurisdiction rule has been established for alimony actions, and in claims for alimony, enforcement proceedings may be initiated not only at the debtor’s place of residence but also at the place of residence of the claimant creditor.

Therefore, the Court should have accepted the request for the removal of the objection to jurisdiction and proceeded to examine the creditor’s other grounds for seeking the removal of the objection, and should have rendered a decision based on the result thereof. Accordingly, the dismissal of the request on the grounds stated above was erroneous.

CONCLUSION: The appeal objections of the creditor are hereby ACCEPTED, and pursuant to Articles 366 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code and 428 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the judgment of the Court is hereby REVERSED for the reasons set forth above. Upon request, the advance court fee shall be refunded. An application for correction of the decision may be made within 10 days from the date of service of the judgment. It was unanimously decided on 18.01.2018.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir