Anasayfa » Blog » Seizure at the Wrong Address Due to a Name Match—Supreme Court Ruling on the Return of the Seized Items One Day Later and the Fact That the Address Was Provided by the Client

Seizure at the Wrong Address Due to a Name Match—Supreme Court Ruling on the Return of the Seized Items One Day Later and the Fact That the Address Was Provided by the Client

Example Of Eviction Promise Of Delivery

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
Court of Cassation
5th Criminal Chamber

Case No.: 2013/13743
Decision No.: 2015/16274
Decision Date: 16.11.2015

Upon the appeal of the judgment rendered by the local court, the case file was examined and the following was considered:

Although it was alleged that the defendant, an attorney registered with the Ankara Bar Association, committed the offense of abuse of office by causing an enforcement order to be served at the address where S.. S.., who had guaranteed the debt, resided during the enforcement proceedings he conducted against the debtors in his capacity as counsel for the creditor, and then, on 12.11.2009, causing the enforcement officers to go to another address where the complainant, who had no connection whatsoever with the debt or the debtor and who merely shared the same first and last name as S.. S.., resided, and, while the complainant was not at home, having the door opened by a locksmith and the belongings seized and placed under custody, thereby causing the complainant to suffer harm; however, considering the contents of the case file, the fact that the complainant’s address had been obtained by the creditor and communicated to the defendant, that pursuant to Articles 80 and 88 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, the authority to conduct the attachment and take movable property into custody belongs to the enforcement office and that these procedures may be carried out in the absence of the creditor’s counsel, that the defendant’s request for an attachment to be carried out at this address was accepted by the enforcement office and the attachment and custody procedures were carried out by the Enforcement Officer in the defendant’s absence, and that, after the complainant stated to the Enforcement Office one day after these procedures that he had no connection with the debt, the defendant requested that the attached property be returned to the complainant, it should have been taken into consideration that there was insufficient evidence establishing that the defendant had acted contrary to the requirements of his duty or had been negligent in the performance of his duty, and he should therefore have been acquitted of the offense charged. Instead, a conviction was rendered based on an erroneous assessment.

Even assuming the foregoing finding to be accepted;

The act established as having been committed should have been regarded as constituting the offense of abuse of office through an affirmative act as set forth in Article 257/1 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, rather than the offense under Article 257/2 of the same Law, and the judgment should have been rendered accordingly.

Although it was accepted that the offense had been committed through the abuse of a right and authority specified in Article 53/1-e of Law No. 5237, Article 53/5 of the same Law was not applied to the defendant.

These matters are contrary to law. Since the defendant’s appellate objections were therefore found to be well-founded, the judgment is hereby REVERSED pursuant to Articles 321 and 326/last of the former Code of Criminal Procedure, with Article 8/1 of Law No. 5320 also taken into consideration.

It was unanimously decided on 16.11.2015.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir