Anasayfa » Blog » Lawsuit for the Recovery of a Stolen Check—Supreme Court Decision on the Determination of Ownership

Lawsuit for the Recovery of a Stolen Check—Supreme Court Decision on the Determination of Ownership

Example Of Eviction Promise Of Delivery

Summary:

The chain of endorsements on the cheque is complete, and it is understood that the defendant is the legitimate holder. The aforementioned statutory provision states: “If a cheque has, for any reason, been taken out of the possession of the holder, whether it is a bearer cheque or a cheque transferable by endorsement and the holder proves his right pursuant to Article 790, the new holder into whose possession the cheque has passed is obliged to return the cheque only if he acquired it in bad faith or was grossly negligent in acquiring it.”

Pursuant to this provision, the defendant is not under an obligation to prove the reason for acquiring the cheque. The defendant must have known, or must have been in a position to know, that the cheque had been taken out of the holder’s possession without consent. Where a cheque has been taken out of the holder’s possession without consent, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff who alleges that he is the legitimate holder of the cheque and that it was taken out of his possession contrary to his consent. The plaintiff must establish this allegation by conclusive and convincing evidence.

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
Court of Cassation
11th Civil Chamber

Case No.: 2014/10768
Decision No.: 2014/20288
Decision Date: 23.12.2014

COURT: ISTANBUL (CLOSED) 47th COMMERCIAL COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
DATE: 07/04/2014
NUMBER: 2012/195-2014/131

In the action between the parties, the judgment rendered by the Istanbul (Closed) 47th Commercial Court of First Instance on 07/04/2014, numbered 2012/195-2014/131, was appealed by counsel for the defendant. Having determined that the appellate petition had been filed within the prescribed period, the report prepared by the Reporting Judge was heard, and after the petitions, written submissions, hearing minutes, and all documents contained in the case file were read and examined, the matter was duly considered and deliberated:

Counsel for the plaintiff stated that, during a robbery that took place at his client’s workplace on 02.02.2012, the cheque numbered 0612133, dated 30.02.2012, drawn on G.. Bank Kasımpaşa Branch, with a face value of TRY 70,000.00 and drawn by the third party A..G.., which is the subject matter of the action, was stolen; that, following the investigation conducted by the Istanbul Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office under Investigation No. 2012/24565 concerning the said theft, an indictment was issued and criminal proceedings were initiated; that the criminal case was pending before the Istanbul 39th Criminal Court of First Instance under Case No. 2012/278; that an action for cancellation due to loss of negotiable instruments had been filed before the Istanbul 26th Commercial Court of First Instance under Case No. 2012/33 concerning the negotiable instruments stolen during the robbery, and an order prohibiting payment had been issued in respect of the stolen cheques; that, in his petition for intervention submitted to the aforementioned proceedings, the defendant had stated that the cheque forming the subject matter of the present action belonged to him and had requested the lifting of the payment prohibition; that the court hearing that case had granted the plaintiff a period of one week to bring an action for restitution against the defendant together with a request for interim relief; that the decision had been served on the plaintiff on 20.07.2012 and that the present action had been filed within the statutory period; that the cheque in question had been obtained by his client from drawer A..G.. pursuant to the debt-credit relationship between them; that, in the case file of the Istanbul 26th Commercial Court of First Instance, Case No. 2012/33, the defendant had stated that he had received the cheque in question from A..S.. and had submitted a delivery and receipt document in this regard; that the said document was dated 13.02.2012 and had therefore been prepared after the theft; that the drawer had notified the bank after the theft; and that the defendant’s failure to inquire with the bank whether there was any problem with the cheque when acquiring it was inconsistent with the ordinary course of commercial life. Accordingly, the plaintiff requested and brought an action seeking an interim injunction concerning the cheque in question, the return of the said cheque to his client, or, alternatively, payment by the defendant to the plaintiff of TRY 70,000.00, representing the face value of the cheque.

Counsel for the defendant requested dismissal of the action.

Based on the entire case file, the evidence collected, and the expert report prepared, the court held that the defendant had no legitimate basis for acquiring the cheque in question and that the cheque, which he was unlawfully holding, was required to be returned to the plaintiff. Accordingly, the court accepted the action and ordered that the cheque numbered 0612133, drawn on G Bank Kasımpaşa Branch, drawn by A G, dated 30.12.2012 and amounting to TRY 70,000.00, be taken from the defendant and returned to the plaintiff.

The judgment was appealed by counsel for the defendant.

The action concerns a claim for restitution based on Article 792 of Law No. 6102, and the court accepted the action on the grounds stated above.

The chain of endorsements on the cheque is complete, and it is understood that the defendant is the legitimate holder. The aforementioned statutory provision states: “If a cheque has, for any reason, been taken out of the possession of the holder, whether it is a bearer cheque or a cheque transferable by endorsement and the holder proves his right pursuant to Article 790, the new holder into whose possession the cheque has passed is obliged to return the cheque only if he acquired it in bad faith or was grossly negligent in acquiring it.”

Pursuant to this provision, the defendant is not under an obligation to prove the reason for acquiring the cheque. The defendant must have known, or must have been in a position to know, that the cheque had been taken out of the holder’s possession without consent. Where a cheque has been taken out of the holder’s possession without consent, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff who alleges that he is the legitimate holder of the cheque and that it was taken out of his possession contrary to his consent. The plaintiff must establish this allegation by conclusive and convincing evidence.

The court failed to establish that the plaintiff was the legitimate holder of the cheque and, by incorrectly assessing the evidence submitted by the defendant, accepted the action on the ground that the defendant was unlawfully holding the cheque. The fact that the defendant acquired the cheque in question after the robbery committed against the plaintiff and that there was no corresponding accounting entry does not establish that the defendant had no commercial relationship with his endorser or that the defendant was grossly negligent in acquiring the cheque.

For these reasons, and also taking into consideration that the defendant was not an accused in the criminal proceedings conducted in connection with the matter, the action should have been dismissed. It was therefore not correct to accept the action, and the appellate objection of counsel for the defendant should be accepted and the judgment should be reversed in favor of the defendant.

RESULT:

For the reasons explained above, the appellate objection of counsel for the defendant is ACCEPTED, and the judgment is hereby REVERSED in favor of the defendant. Upon request, the advance appellate fee paid by the appellant shall be refunded to the appellant.

It was unanimously decided on 23.12.2014.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir