Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Decision On The Fault Of The Administration In Filling Potholes In The Road

Supreme Court Decision On The Fault Of The Administration In Filling Potholes In The Road

Council of State, 15th Chamber

 

Case No: 2013/10673

 

Decision No: 2017/40

 

Summary of the Claim: The plaintiff filed a lawsuit claiming that the damages amounting to 30,083.25 TL, resulting from an accident on August 27, 2008, involving the vehicle with license plate 34 DR 3239, insured under a comprehensive insurance policy, on the road between Odunluk Pier and Geyikli in Geyikli Village, Ezine District, Çanakkale Province, were due to the negligence of the administration for failing to maintain and repair the potholes on the road. The plaintiff requested that the damages be compensated by the negligent administration, along with legal interest accruing from October 22, 2008. The Çanakkale Administrative Court ruled as follows: The Forensic Medicine Institute’s report dated 23/03/2011 stated that the defendant administration was 25% at fault for the accident due to its failure to maintain and repair potholes on the road, and that the total damage amounted to 37,000 TL. The court ruled that the defendant administration should compensate for 9,250.00 TL, calculated based on its fault percentage, along with legal interest accruing from the date of filing the lawsuit, and rejected the claim for additional material damages. The defendant administration is appealing this decision, arguing that it is not in accordance with the law.

 

Summary of the Defense: No defense has been submitted.

 

Opinion: It is considered that the appeal should be rejected.

 

ON BEHALF OF THE TURKISH NATION

 

The Fifteenth Chamber of the Council of State, having heard the explanations of the examining judge and reviewed the documents in the file, considered the matter as follows:

 

Article 49, paragraph 2 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, titled “Annulment of the Decision,” stipulates that the Council of State may annul a decision under review on appeal for the following reasons: a) The case was handled outside the scope of its jurisdiction and authority; b) An unlawful decision was rendered; c) There are errors or deficiencies in the application of procedural rules that could affect the decision. Based on the examination of the documents in the file and the claims in the appeal petition, it has been concluded that the decision subject to appeal is in accordance with the law and procedure, and that there is no legal reason requiring the annulment of the decision.

 

For the reasons explained above; The appeal request is rejected, the decision of the Çanakkale Administrative Court dated 12/05/2011, numbered E:2009/473, K:2011/396, is UPHELD, the file is sent to the Court, and in accordance with the first paragraph of Article 8 and the first paragraph of Article 54 of Law No. 2577, added by Law No. 6545 dated 18.06.2014, the right to request a correction of the decision is open within fifteen days from the day following the date of notification of this decision, unanimously decided on 09/01/2017.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir