Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Decision On Damages Caused By Rockfalls On Roads

Supreme Court Decision On Damages Caused By Rockfalls On Roads

Request For Correction Of Gender Registration

Council of State, 15th Chamber Presidency

Case No: 2016/186

Decision No: 2016/1423

 

Summary of the Request: It is requested that the decision of the Antalya 4th Administrative Court dated 12/10/2015, case number E:2015/327; K:2015/64, be reviewed and overturned on the grounds that it is not in accordance with the law.

 

Summary of the Defense: No defense has been submitted.

 

Opinion: In accordance with Law No. 2918, since the resolution of the dispute is within the jurisdiction of the Administrative Court, it is considered that the Administrative Court’s decision to dismiss the case on grounds of jurisdiction should be overturned.

 

ON BEHALF OF THE TURKISH NATION

 

The Fifteenth Chamber of the Council of State, having heard the explanations of the Examining Judge and examined the documents in the file, considered the matter as follows:

 

The case; This lawsuit was filed by the plaintiff requesting payment of 37,605.00 TL for repair costs, transportation and depreciation, 1,000.00 TL for loss of earnings, and 20,000.00 TL for moral damages, along with legal interest, due to the collision of the commercial transport vehicle with license plate number ……, under the control and management of the plaintiff, with rocks that fell onto the road in the Kızılcadağ area while traveling from Korkuteli to Fethiye on February 24, 2015.

 

The Antalya 4th Administrative Court, citing Article 110 of Law No. 2918, ruled that the case should be dismissed on grounds of lack of jurisdiction pursuant to Article 15/1-a of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, on the grounds that the judicial courts have jurisdiction to hear and resolve the dispute.

 

The defendant administration is requesting that the aforementioned Administrative Court decision be reviewed and overturned on appeal, claiming it is unlawful. To clarify the matter, it is first necessary to examine the relevant legislation in detail:

 

According to Law No. 6001 on Organization and Duties, the General Directorate of Highways, a public institution with a special budget and public legal personality, is responsible and authorized for constructing, commissioning, ensuring the safe use of, repairing, operating, and managing highways. There is no doubt that the public service of highway construction, maintenance, and operation will be carried out in accordance with the principles and rules of administrative law; and that disputes arising from the administrative actions and activities of the aforementioned General Directorate should be resolved in administrative courts in accordance with Article 125 of the Constitution and Article 2 of Law No. 2577. The amendment made to the Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 by Law No. 6099 does not contain a new regulation regarding the legal responsibility of the General Directorate of Highways for the execution of road construction and maintenance services; it does not change the judicial procedure.

 

Article 110 of Law No. 2918, as amended by Article 14 of Law No. 6099 dated January 19, 2011, titled “Competent and Authorized Court,” states: “Liability lawsuits arising from this Law, including those relating to damages caused by vehicles operated or owned by the State and other public institutions, shall be heard in the judicial courts. The fact that the injured party is a public official does not prevent the application of this provision. The provisions of this Law shall also apply to train-traffic accidents occurring at level crossings. Lawsuits concerning legal liability arising from motor vehicle accidents may be filed in one of the courts located where the insurer’s headquarters or branch is located, or where the insurance contract was made by the agent, or in the court of the place where the accident occurred.”

 

The aforementioned legal provision emphasizes that the competent court is limited to cases where the rules regarding legal liability contained in Law No. 2918 apply, using the phrase “liability lawsuits arising from this Law.” Therefore, when determining the competent court, it is necessary to ascertain whether the liability rules regulated in the aforementioned Law, which are limited to damages caused by motor vehicles, apply to the dispute in question.

 

Law No. 2918, which aims to ensure traffic safety in terms of life and property on highways and to determine all measures related to traffic safety, has defined the duties and powers of the General Directorate of Security, the Ministry of National Education, the Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock, the Ministry of Transport, Maritime Affairs and Communications, and the Ministry of Transport, Maritime Affairs and Communications, in terms of traffic safety. However, the Law does not regulate the legal responsibilities of other public administrations, including the Ministry of Transport, Maritime Affairs and Communications, for the public services they undertake regarding traffic order and traffic safety.

 

The eighth section of Law No. 2918, titled “Legal Responsibility and Insurance,” regulates the legal responsibility of the owner of the enterprise to which the vehicle operator is affiliated; in other words, the legal responsibility of vehicle owners and operators for damages arising from traffic accidents involving motor vehicles.

When the provisions of the eighth section of Law No. 2918 concerning legal responsibility are considered together, it becomes clear that the judicial courts have jurisdiction over the examination and resolution of all lawsuits filed against vehicle owners and operators, including those filed against public administrations and institutions in their capacity as vehicle operators, due to accidents involving motor vehicles belonging to the State and other public institutions. However, given that the services provided by public administrations and institutions to ensure traffic safety and order, both according to their own founding laws and the Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, are considered public services, and since the responsibilities of the public administrations and institutions assigned in Law No. 2918 are not separately regulated; the administrative courts have jurisdiction over the examination and resolution of lawsuits filed against the relevant administrations seeking compensation for damages alleged to arise from traffic order and safety services. In conclusion, the duties of the relevant authorities, as defined in their founding laws and reiterated in Law No. 2918, namely; The legal responsibility of the defendant administration arising from its public service of road construction, maintenance, operation, and ensuring traffic safety must be determined according to the principles and rules of administrative law; therefore, full-fledged lawsuits filed for this reason must be resolved in administrative courts.

 

Examination of the case file reveals that the lawsuit under appeal was filed with a claim for compensation for damages arising from an alleged incident, alleging that the defendant administration committed a service fault due to insufficient measures taken on the highway under its maintenance and responsibility.

 

In this respect, the dispute does not stem from the legal responsibility of the vehicle operator under private law, but rather from the claim that the duties stipulated in Law No. 6001—namely, maintaining, repairing, operating, cleaning, and ensuring traffic safety on highways—were not fully and completely fulfilled, and therefore, the services provided were operated defectively, resulting in damages due to service fault. Accordingly, the case falls under the jurisdiction of administrative courts for examination and resolution.

 

In this case, while the Administrative Court should have examined the merits of the dispute and rendered a decision, the decision to dismiss the case on grounds of jurisdiction is deemed legally incorrect.

 

For the reasons explained above, the decision of the Antalya 4th Administrative Court dated 12/10/2015, numbered E:2015/327; K:2015/64, is hereby REVERSED, and the case is remanded to the aforementioned court for a new decision. In accordance with Article 54, paragraph 1 of Law No. 2577, the right to appeal this decision is open within fifteen days from the date of notification. This decision was reached unanimously on 07/03/2016.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir