Anasayfa » Blog » Does Publishing A Person’s Home Address In A News Report Violate The Right To Privacy? Should Compensation Be Awarded? Supreme Court Decision

Does Publishing A Person’s Home Address In A News Report Violate The Right To Privacy? Should Compensation Be Awarded? Supreme Court Decision

SUMMARY: This case concerns a claim for moral damages based on an attack on personal rights through the press. An individual’s home address is personal data or information falling within the scope of private life and therefore benefits from the protection afforded to them. The publication of the plaintiff’s public address constitutes a violation of the right to privacy. It cannot be argued that the inclusion of this information in the news report served a public interest. While it was possible to publish this information, which falls within the scope of private life, by redacting or deleting it, the failure to take this into account in the presentation of the news undoubtedly warrants compensation. For these reasons, while a suitable amount of moral damages should have been awarded in favor of the plaintiff, the decision to dismiss the case with erroneous reasoning is not in accordance with procedural rules and law, therefore the decision must be overturned.

 

Republic of Turkey SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

 

4th Civil Chamber

Case No: 2014/16369

Decision No: 2015/13675

Decision Date: November 26, 2015

 

CLAIM FOR NON-PECUNIARY DAMAGES – AN INDIVIDUAL’S HOME ADDRESS IS PERSONAL INFORMATION FALLING WITHIN THE SCOPE OF PRIVATE LIFE AND THEREFORE HE/SHE IS ENTITLED TO PROTECTION – PUBLICATION OF THE PLAINTIFF’S FULL ADDRESS VIOLATED THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY – ANNULMENT OF THE JUDGMENT

 

(Law No. 2709, Article 20) (Law No. 5237, Article 134)

 

Case: Plaintiff A. A. represented by attorney E. Ç., against defendants H. Y. and Following a lawsuit filed on February 17, 2014, against the others seeking moral damages, and after a trial conducted by the court, the decision of September 11, 2014, rejecting the case was appealed to the Supreme Court by the plaintiff’s attorney within the prescribed time limit. After the acceptance of the appeal petition, the case was reviewed by the examining judge, who prepared a report based on the documents in the file.

 

Decision:

 

1- Based on the documents in the file, the evidence on which the decision is based, and the legally sound reasons, particularly the lack of any inaccuracy in the evaluation of the evidence, the plaintiff’s appeals against defendant M. A., and against the other defendants except those covered in the following paragraph, should be rejected.

 

2- Regarding the plaintiff’s other appeal against defendants H. Y. and G. A.:

 

The case concerns a claim for moral damages based on an attack on personal rights through the press. The court decided to reject the case; The judgment was appealed by the plaintiff.

 

The plaintiff claimed that A.P. was bitten by a dog while out for a walk, that he filed a complaint, that A.V. authorized an investigation against the relevant parties, that the investigation resulted in a decision of no grounds for prosecution, that this decision was published in the February 7, 2014 issue of E.G. under the headline “…”, and that the full text of the decision of no grounds for prosecution, including his name, surname, parents’ names, date of birth, and full address, was published in the newspaper and on its website without any redaction or deletion, and therefore demanded compensation for moral damages.

 

The defendants argued that the mention of a person’s name in a news article does not constitute an attack on their personal rights, and that the newspaper’s editor-in-chief was not liable, therefore the case should be dismissed.

 

The court dismissed the case on the grounds that the news published in the February 7, 2014 issue of E.G. did not contain any statement that constituted an attack on the plaintiff’s personal rights, that the publication of the decision of non-prosecution did not constitute an attack on personal rights, that the content of the decision did not contain any information or statement that would humiliate or ridicule the plaintiff if made public, and that the editor-in-chief, M.A., was not liable for damages.

 

As stated in the court’s reasoning, the published news is considered within the limits of freedom of the press because it is consistent with apparent reality and current, and the balance between content and form in the expressions used was maintained. There is also no illegality in the visual publication of the decision of non-prosecution within the news content. This is a necessary journalistic technique to draw the reader’s attention to the news. However, the aforementioned decision text also includes the plaintiff’s full address information, and this information was published in its entirety in the news without being redacted or removed from the text.

 

In the decision of A.T., application number 42811/06, dated 09/10/2012, it was stated: “According to Article 8 of the Convention, everyone has the right to respect for their private and family life, their home and their correspondence… Article 8 of the Convention also protects the right to respect for an individual’s home, which is a physically specific place where private and family life develops… An individual’s home address is a personal data or information falling within the scope of private life and therefore benefits from the protection afforded to them…”

As stated in the decision quoted above, an individual’s home address is a personal data or information falling within the scope of private life and therefore will benefit from the protection afforded to it. The publication of the plaintiff’s full address constitutes a violation of the right to privacy. It cannot be argued that there is a public interest in including this information in the news report. While it was possible to publish this information, which falls within the scope of private life, by redacting or deleting it, the failure to take this into account in the presentation of the news report undoubtedly warrants compensation. For the reasons explained, while a suitable amount of moral damages should have been awarded in favor of the plaintiff, the decision to dismiss the case with erroneous reasoning is not in accordance with procedure and law, therefore the decision must be overturned.

 

Conclusion: The appealed decision is hereby REVERSED for the reasons shown in paragraph (2) above, and the plaintiff’s appeals against defendant M. A. and other defendants are REJECTED for the reasons shown in paragraph (1) above, by unanimous decision on 26/11/2015.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir