Anasayfa » Blog » Claim For Payment Of Overtime Pay – Discretionary Reduction Of Payment – Supreme Court Decision

Claim For Payment Of Overtime Pay – Discretionary Reduction Of Payment – Supreme Court Decision

Eviction Of The Workplace Due To Necessity Supreme Court Decision

Republic of Turkey

SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

9TH CIVIL CHAMBER

E. 2017/6387

K. 2018/8929

T. 17.4.2018

 

* CLAIM FOR PAYMENT OF OVERTIME PAY (It has become a consistent practice that when overtime work is calculated for a long period and the amount is high, a reasonable reduction should be made – The reduction should be determined according to the worker’s working style, the organization of the work, and the calculated overtime amount – A reduction that would eliminate the essence of the right cannot be made)

 

* DISCRETIONARY REDUCTION (A discretionary reduction can be made in case the worker is unable to work from time to time due to reasons such as illness, excused absence, or weekend leave – Making a reduction of more than 50% that would affect the essence of the right necessitates reversal) )

 

* REASONABLE REDUCTION (The plaintiff’s overtime work was determined based on witness statements – While a discretionary reduction in overtime pay is appropriate considering the possibility of occasional absences due to illness, excuses, leave, or weekend holidays, a 50% reduction that significantly impacts the essence of the right is not permissible – The court should have applied a more reasonable reduction that does not affect the essence of the right)

 

485/m.41

 

SUMMARY: The lawsuit concerns a claim for payment of overtime wages.

 

The plaintiff’s overtime work was determined based on witness statements, and while a discretionary reduction in overtime pay is appropriate considering the possibility of occasional absences due to illness, excuses, leave, or weekend holidays, a 50% reduction that significantly impacts the essence of the right is incorrect. Since the court should have applied a more reasonable reduction that does not affect the essence of the right, the judgment must be overturned.

 

CASE: The plaintiff requested a ruling ordering the payment of overtime wages.

 

The local court partially accepted the claim.

 

Since the parties, through their lawyers, appealed within the prescribed time limit, the case file was examined after hearing the report prepared by the Examining Judge, and the necessary discussions and considerations were made:

 

DECISION: A-) Summary of the Plaintiff’s Claim:

 

The plaintiff’s attorney claimed that the plaintiff worked at the defendant company’s Bursa branch between April 9, 2007, and September 10, 2013, and that although the normal working hours were from 08:30 to 18:00, the earliest evening shift ended at 21:00/21:30 without a break, and that overtime wages were not paid, therefore requesting payment of overtime wages.

 

B-) Summary of the Defendant’s Response:

 

The defendant’s attorney argued that the plaintiff’s claim of working overtime was contrary to the ordinary course of life, that the plaintiff accepted that overtime work up to 3 hours per day and work on weekends were included in the plaintiff’s salary according to Article 8 of the employment contract, that even overtime work performed by the plaintiff as required by the job at certain times was paid in full or the plaintiff was granted leave, that overtime payments were indicated on the payrolls, that the plaintiff signed the payrolls without reservation, and that the plaintiff’s claim was time-barred, requesting the dismissal of the case.

 

C) Summary of the Local Court Decision:

 

Based on the evidence gathered and the expert report, the court ruled that the plaintiff worked overtime during their employment at the defendant’s workplace, but considering that the plaintiff may have had days off due to leave, excuses, or illness, a discretionary reduction of 50% was applied to the calculated overtime pay, thus partially accepting the claim.

 

D) Appeal:

 

Both parties appealed the decision.

 

E) Justification:

 

1) Based on the documents in the file, the evidence gathered, and the legal grounds on which the decision is based, all of the defendant’s appeals and the plaintiff’s appeals, except those covered in the following paragraph, are unfounded.

 

2) In recent years, the Supreme Court has consistently applied a reasonable reduction based on presumption when overtime work is calculated for a long period and the amount is high. The reduction should be determined according to the employee’s working style, the organization of the work, and the calculated overtime amount. A reduction that would negate the essence of the right should not be applied (Supreme Court 9th Civil Chamber, March 21, 2012, Case No. 2009/48913 E, Decision No. 2012/9400 K).

 

In the specific dispute, it has been determined based on witness statements that the plaintiff worked overtime. While a discretionary reduction is appropriate considering the possibility of the plaintiff being unable to work from time to time due to illness, excuses, leave, or weekend holidays, applying a 50% reduction that would affect the essence of the right is incorrect. The court should apply a more reasonable reduction that does not affect the essence of the right.

 

CONCLUSION: For the reasons stated above, the appealed decision is REVERSED. The advance appeal fee shall be returned to the relevant party upon request. The decision was made unanimously on April 17, 2018.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir