Anasayfa » Blog » When It Is Understanding That The Plaintiff-counterdefendant Spouse Is Also Right To File A Lawsuit, Should The Case Of Both Spouses Be Accepted?

When It Is Understanding That The Plaintiff-counterdefendant Spouse Is Also Right To File A Lawsuit, Should The Case Of Both Spouses Be Accepted?

Violation Of The Right To Liberty And Security Of The Person Due To Insufficient Compensation Paid For Detention Measures

T.R. Supreme Court

 

2.Legal Department

Basis: 2016/10179

Decision: 2018/1176

Decision Date: 25.01.2018

 

DIVORCE CASE – THERE IS A DISAGREEMENT BETWEEN THE PARTIES THAT WILL SHAKE THE SHARE LIFE TO THE FOUNDATIONS AND WHICH WILL NOT ALLOW THE CONTINUATION OF THE UNION – THE NEED TO DECIDE TO DIVORCE WITH THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE MAN’S CASE.

 

SUMMARY: There is a permanent incompatibility between the parties that will shake the common life to its foundations and will not allow the continuation of the union. Given the course of events, the plaintiff-defendant man is also right to file a lawsuit. Since it is no longer legally possible to force spouses to live together under these conditions, it was not found correct to reject the man’s case with insufficient justification, instead of deciding to divorce by accepting the case of the plaintiff-defendant man.

 

(4721 S.K. art. 166)

 

At the end of the trial of the case between the parties, the decision given by the local court, date and number shown above, is made by the plaintiff-counterdefendant male in terms of rejection of the main case, determination of fault, financial compensation, attorney’s fee; The defendant-counterclaimant woman appealed for the determination of fault and compensation, and the document was read and the necessary discussions were made:

 

1- According to the articles in the file, the evidence on which the decision is based, the legal reasons, and especially the fact that there is no mistake in the appreciation of the evidence, all the appeal objections of the defendant-counter-plaintiff woman and the plaintiff-counter-defendant man, which are outside the scope of the following paragraph, are unfounded.

 

2- The investigation carried out, based on the evidence collected, in the events that caused the marriage union to be shaken from its foundation; Both parties are at fault in not being able to establish a joint life, in addition to this fault detected and determined by the court, the plaintiff-counter-defendant man neglected his marital duties, did not provide independent housing and was seriously at fault compared to the defendant-counter-plaintiff woman, there was no benefit worth protecting in the marital union for the parties, Article 166/2 of the Turkish Civil Code. It is understood that the conditions of the article are met. In this case, there is a discord between the parties that will shake the foundations of common life and prevent the continuation of the union. Given the course of events, the plaintiff-defendant man is also right to file a lawsuit. Since it is no longer legally possible to force spouses to live together under these conditions, it was not found correct to reject the man’s case with insufficient justification, instead of deciding on divorce (TCC Art. 166/1-2) by accepting the plaintiff-defendant man’s case.

 

However, it was decided to accept the divorce case filed by the defendant-counter-plaintiff woman, and since the decision was finalized without appeal, the plaintiff-counter-defendant man’s divorce case remained irrelevant. For this reason, the court had to overturn the verdict in order to rule that “there is no need to make a decision” since the man’s case remained irrelevant and to decide on the trial expenses and attorney’s fee depending on the justification of the case.

 

Result: The appealed judgment shall be REVERSED for the reason explained in the 2nd paragraph above, the parts of the judgment that are outside the scope of reversal shall be APPROVED for the reason stated in the 1st paragraph above, the fee written below shall be charged…, since the 143.50 TL appeal application fee has been paid in advance, there is no need to charge any other fee, the appeal advance fee shall be returned to the depositor T… upon request, within 15 days from the notification of this decision. The decision was taken unanimously, with the possibility of correction. 25.01.2018

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir