Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Decision On Payment Of The Money Entering The Executive Sector To The Creditor Before The Execution Proceeding Is Finalized

Supreme Court Decision On Payment Of The Money Entering The Executive Sector To The Creditor Before The Execution Proceeding Is Finalized

T.R.

Supreme Court

12. LEGAL DEPARTMENT

CORE NO: 2016/3551

DECISION NO: 2016/17359

DECISION DATE: 20.6.2016

 

>Since it is not correct for the money entered into the Execution Office’s safe before the proceedings are finalised, to be paid to the creditor or to be fully executed, it should be requested to the enforcement office’s safe.

 

SUMMARY: After the non-judgment proceedings are finalized irregularly and the money is collected from the debtor through seizure, if the Enforcement Court decides to suspend the proceedings due to the irregularity of the notification, requesting the refund of the money paid to the creditor…

“Since the prosecution has not yet been finalized, it would not be correct for the money entered in the enforcement directorate’s safe to be paid to the creditor, and for the file to be fully executed based on this payment in a prosecution that has not been duly finalized, the money paid in question should be requested to the enforcement directorate’s safe (the file number is stated and the enforcement office’s bank account number).”

 

Upon the request of the creditor to be examined within the period of the court decision with the date and number written above, the file regarding this case was sent to the office from the locality, and after listening to the report prepared by the Examining Judge for the case file and reading and examining all the documents in the file, the need for the case was discussed and considered:

 

DECISION

 

In the follow-up through general seizure initiated by the creditor, after the money deposited in the file as a result of the imposed seizure is paid to the creditor, it is decided to accept the debtor’s complaint regarding the irregularity of the payment order notification process (to suspend the pursuit by the enforcement directorate in accordance with Article 62 of the EBL, due to the objection made in time), and the debtor’s representative’s request to send a memorandum to the creditor for the refund of the money paid to the creditor in accordance with Article 361 of the EBL is decided by the enforcement directorate. It was rejected, and the debtor’s representative applied to the enforcement court to request the annulment of this rejection decision.

 

The court decided to accept the complaint and the decision was; With the decision of our department dated 02.07.2015 and numbered 2015/6081 E.-2015/18830 K., “In accordance with Article 361 of the EBL, if it is understood as a result of the account that more money was collected from the debtor and given to the creditor by the enforcement offices, or that money was paid to a party by mistake, the money given will be taken back from that person without the need for a separate judgment. However, the EBL In order for the provision of Article 361 to be implemented, the enforcement office must have collected excessive money from the debtor or a payment must have been made by mistake. The decision to accept the irregular notification complaint does not invalidate the deductions made previously. Therefore, the decision to accept the debtor’s irregular notification complaint and the suspension of the proceedings due to objection is not sufficient to accept that the conditions of Article 361 of the EBL are met. However, in this case, since the proceeding has not yet been finalized, the money entered into the enforcement directorate’s safe should be paid to the creditor, and since it would not be correct for the file to be fully executed based on this payment in a prosecution that has not been duly finalized, the said money should be requested to the enforcement directorate’s safe (the bank account number of the enforcement office by reporting the file number).

This time, the court complied with the reversal order, and by submitting the reversal order, the court decided that there was no need to make a decision on the case that remained unsubject, since it was understood that the enforcement directorate had issued a memorandum to the creditor’s attorney to return the 46,798.11 TL paid to the creditor in line with the reversal order, to the coffers of the enforcement directorate, upon the request of the debtor’s attorney.

 

By deciding to comply with the reversal order, the court arose a procedural right for the benefit of the party in favor of reversal to examine and make a decision in accordance with the reversal. In this case, the local court, which complies with the reversal order, is obliged to take action and decide in accordance with the reversal order. In that case, while the court should have decided to take action in line with the reversal order, it is inappropriate to reach a conclusion in writing on the grounds that the action was taken by the enforcement directorate and there is no further issue.

 

RESULT: With the acceptance of the creditor’s appeal objections, it was unanimously decided on 20/06/2016 to REVERSE the court decision for the above-mentioned reasons, in accordance with Article 366 of the EBL and Article 428 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and to refund the fee collected in advance, if requested, with the possibility of correcting the decision within 10 days from the notifi cation of the decision.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir