Anasayfa » Blog » How Should The Rental Fee Be Determined In Ecrmisil Cases?

How Should The Rental Fee Be Determined In Ecrmisil Cases?

Request For Correction Of Gender Registration

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE COURT OF CASSATION 1st Civil Chamber

 

Basis No: 2015/13026

 

Decision No: 2018/13

 

Date: 08.01.2018

 

SUBJECT: Action for the Cancellation of Objection – Ecrimisil (Equitable Remuneration for Unjust Occupation) – Determination of the rental value that the immovable property could yield under free-market conditions in its existing state during the initial period – Requirement to apply the PPI (Producer Price Index) increase rate to the rental value of the initial period for subsequent periods – Requirement to reject the request for execution denial indemnity (icra inkar tazminatı).

 

S U M M A R Y

The court must determine the rental value that the subject immovable property could yield under free-market conditions in its existing state during the initial period. For subsequent periods, the ecrimisil must be calculated by applying the full PPI increase rate to the amount determined for the initial period. Furthermore, since ecrimisil claims do not constitute a “liquidated” (likit) debt, the plaintiff’s request for execution denial indemnity must be rejected. The local court’s judgment, based on erroneous evaluation and incomplete examination, is improper.

 

J U D G M E N T

1. Definition of Ecrimisil: As expressed in doctrine and judicial practice, ecrimisil is a compensation that a non-possessing owner may claim from a bad-faith possessor who is not the owner. According to the Unified Judgment of the Court of Cassation (08.03.1950, 22/4), unjust occupation (fuzuli işgal) cannot be likened to a lease agreement; it is inherently a tortious act (haksız eylem).

 

2. Calculation Method: The calculation of ecrimisil requires expertise. A discovery and examination must be conducted by experts suitable for the nature of the property.

 

Initial Period: The rental value should be determined based on local market rates, considering the size, quality, and environmental features of the property, compared with comparable lease agreements (emsal kira sözleşmeleri).

 

Subsequent Periods: The value for subsequent years must be calculated by reflecting the full PPI (Producer Price Index – ÜFE) increase rate upon the initial period’s value.

 

3. Execution Denial Indemnity: Ecrimisil is a form of compensation arising from a tortious act and is not considered a liquidated (certain) debt. Therefore, it is legally incorrect to award execution denial indemnity (the penalty for objecting to a certain debt) in such cases.

 

CONCLUSION: The decision of the local court is REVERSED (BOZULMASINA) on 08.01.2018.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir