Anasayfa » Blog » Does a Sale Made by the Deceased to a Person They Lived With Out of Wedlock Create Fraudulent Conveyance?

Does a Sale Made by the Deceased to a Person They Lived With Out of Wedlock Create Fraudulent Conveyance?

Request For Correction Of Gender Registration

The deliberate mismatch between intent and declaration is called collusion. There are two types of collusion:

Absolute collusion is when the parties, with the intent to deceive third parties, agree to create an appearance that does not reflect their true intent and does not produce any legal effect or consequence, even though they do not actually have the intent to enter into a contract, but appear to do so.

Relative muvazaa is when the parties conceal a contract made in accordance with their true intentions by creating an appearance of a contract that does not correspond to their intentions.

Fraudulent conveyance is a type of relative fraud. It is when the testator, aiming to deprive the heir of their inheritance rights, conceals their true intention and transfers the immovable property they actually wish to donate by declaring their intention to sell it in the contract they make at the land registry.

Fraud applies to bilateral transactions. Fraudulent conveyance cannot be claimed in dispositions dependent on death, which are unilateral declarations of intent.
(“According to the documents in the file, the evidence on which the decision is based, and the legal grounds, and in particular, fraudulent conveyance applies to bilateral transactions, and cannot be claimed in dispositions dependent on death, which are unilateral declarations of intent, and the will does not contain any conditions that are contrary to the law, the appellant’s appeals outside the scope of the following paragraph are unfounded.” T.C. COURT OF CASSATION 2nd CIVIL CHAMBER E. 2006/19259 K. 2007/13908)

Persons who have a legal interest in bringing a lawsuit as a result of fraudulent conveyance and who are heirs may file a lawsuit for the cancellation and registration of the title deed. Fraudulent conveyance by the deceased can be proven by any legal evidence. (For example, it can be proven by facts such as the personal relationship between the deceased and the defendant, whether the defendant had the purchasing power, whether the events occurred in the normal course of events, etc.) There is no statute of limitations for lawsuits for cancellation and registration of title deeds to be filed as a result of fraudulent conveyance by the deceased; a lawsuit may be filed at any time.

The Supreme Court decision on this matter is as follows:

SUPREME COURT OF TURKEY 2nd CIVIL CHAMBER E. 2007/2074 K. 2007/4093 T. 15.3.2007

SUMMARY: The plaintiff’s claim is not related to reduction but is based on the deceased’s fraud (due to the defendant disposing of the real estate before the lawsuit) and relates to the claim in proportion to the inheritance share. The evidence gathered shows that the defendant had been cohabiting with the other defendant since 1996 without being married, that the two later married officially, and that the real estate in question was transferred by the deceased to the defendant during their cohabitation, ostensibly by way of sale but in reality without consideration, and that the apparent sale was a sham. In this case, it is necessary to rule on the plaintiff’s claim in proportion to his inheritance share based on the real value of the immovable properties at the time they were disposed of by the defendant, and the rejection of the claim is not considered correct.

CASE: The judgment dated, numbered, and subject mattered above was affirmed by the Chamber’s decision dated 12.12.2006 and numbered 6127-17427. The documents were read, and the matter was discussed and considered, with a request for correction of the aforementioned decision of our Chamber.

DECISION: The plaintiff; the deceased (her mother) Feriha, on January 19, 2005, leaving behind himself and his brother Halil as legal heirs. The decedent transferred apartment no. 8 in the apartment building registered under parcel no. 59 in the Kahramanlar neighborhood of Izmir on August 12, 2002, and the immovable property registered under parcel no. 1981 in the village of Kepez, Çanakkale, to his brother Halil’s common-law wife Mehlike on August 12, 2002, by way of sale. 8, 2002, to his brother Halil’s common-law wife Mehlike, by showing a sale. He claims that the transfer was not actually a sale but a gift, that no consideration was paid in return, that the transaction was made with the aim of evading inheritance and depriving the plaintiff of his inheritance rights in these properties, and that it was based on collusion. Since the defendant Mehlike subsequently sold these properties to third parties, the plaintiff is now compelled to assert his claim for the amount corresponding to his inheritance share. Therefore, while reserving his rights to any additional claims, he requests that the defendants be jointly and severally ordered to pay 60,000 YTL from the inheritance share due to the fraudulent transaction.

The defendants’ attorney requested that the case be dismissed, stating that the properties in question were purchased by their client and that there was no collusion in the transaction.

The court dismissed the case on the grounds that “…it has not been proven that there was collusion in the purchase of the properties by the defendant Mehlike, who is a third party…”

The Court of Cassation upheld the ruling upon the plaintiff’s appeal. The Court of Cassation’s decision to uphold the ruling stated that “…the dispositions of the deceased were gifts,” but “…it could not be proven that this gift was made with the intent to infringe upon the plaintiff’s reserved share.”

The plaintiff requested a correction of the decision.

 

The plaintiff’s claim is not related to reduction but is based on the deceased’s fraud (due to the defendant disposing of the real estate before the lawsuit) and relates to the inheritance share. From the evidence gathered; it is understood that the defendant Halil had been living with the other defendant Mehlike without being married since 1996, that these two were officially married on February 28, 2004, and that the real estate in question was transferred by the testator to the defendant Mehlike during their unmarried cohabitation, ostensibly by way of sale but in reality without consideration, and that the apparent sale transaction was fraudulent. In this case, it is necessary to rule that the plaintiff is entitled to a share of the real estate based on its actual value at the time it was disposed of by the defendant, and the rejection of the claim is not considered correct. However, since this aspect was overlooked during the initial review and the ruling was upheld, it is necessary to accept the plaintiff’s request for a correction of the decision, revoke our Chamber’s decision to uphold the ruling, and overturn the local court’s decision.

CONCLUSION: Pursuant to Article 440/1-4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiff’s request for correction of the decision is accepted, our Chamber’s affirmation decision dated 12.12.2006, numbered 2006/6127-17427, is revoked, the local court’s decision is REVERSED for the reasons stated above, The appeal advance correction fee paid by the plaintiff shall be refunded to the plaintiff. This decision was made unanimously on March 15, 2007.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir