Anasayfa » Blog » Compensation for Loss of Value in Vehicle Traffic Accidents

Compensation for Loss of Value in Vehicle Traffic Accidents

Damaged vehicles, especially motor vehicles, may lose value despite repairs.

 

The loss of value generally depends on whether the vehicle has not reached the end of its useful life, has not been involved in a previous accident and has not been repaired, and has been used with care.

 

These factors, in particular, should be evaluated based on its original condition. Just having been used for a certain period (age), does not necessarily mean it has reached the end of its useful life. For example, a motor vehicle that has maintained its original condition due to having been used meticulously and well-maintained and not previously involved in an accident or repair, may also lose value, regardless of its age.

 

When a materially damaging traffic accident occurs, the loss of value of the vehicle can be compensated in two ways. The first is general litigation, and the second is through a dispute resolution application to the Insurance Arbitration Commission.

 

A-) GENERAL ACTIONS

 

1- FAULT REQUIREMENT IN VEHICLE LOSS OF VALUE COMPENSATION LAWSUIT:

 

According to Article 49 of the Code of Obligations, anyone who injures another through a negligent and unlawful act is liable to repair the damage.

 

Repair costs for a vehicle not at fault resulting from a traffic accident are covered by the other party’s insurance company under the other party’s compulsory traffic insurance. However, a damage report is recorded for the vehicle involved in the accident, and this situation becomes a problem for the vehicle owner when they want to sell their vehicle. This results in a difference in value between a vehicle of the same model, make, and specification that has not been involved in an accident and one that has been involved in an accident. In short, a vehicle with a damage report is unpopular in the used car market, and its resale value decreases, resulting in a loss of value.

 

If your vehicle has lost value due to a traffic accident involving material damage, you must file a claim for loss of value compensation based on your degree of fault in the accident. For example, a lawsuit filed by the owner of the vehicle that caused the accident and is deemed 100% at fault will be dismissed.

 

2- HOW LONG DOES A VEHICLE DEPRECIATION CASE TAKE TO CONCLUDES:

 

Vehicle depreciation lawsuits resulting from traffic accidents typically take between 9 months and 1.5 years to conclude.

 

If you rented your vehicle during the period you were unable to use it, you can also seek compensation for the cost. If your vehicle is a commercial vehicle, you can also seek compensation for the damages incurred during the period you were unable to use it.

 

3- WHO CAN A VEHICLE DEPRECIATION CASE TAKE AGAINST:

 

Referring a vehicle depreciation claim to the insurance company will undoubtedly be more favorable to the claimant, given the insurance company’s ability to pay.

 

If the driver and the vehicle registration holder are different, a lawsuit can be filed against either party for the depreciation claim, or the driver and registration holder can be filed jointly.

 

4-WHERE SHOULD A VEHICLE DEPRECIATION COMPENSATION CASE BE FILED?

 

According to Article 2 of the Civil Procedure Code (CCP), the competent court for claims concerning property rights, regardless of the value and amount of the subject matter in the lawsuit, and for claims concerning personal property, is the civil court of first instance unless otherwise stipulated.

 

Under this regulation, the competent court for claims for claims for loss of value of a vehicle is also the civil court of first instance.

 

If the claim for loss of value is filed against an insurance company, the competent court is the Commercial Court of First Instance.

 

The competent court for claims for loss of value of a vehicle is determined in accordance with Article 16 of the Civil Procedure Code (CCP). Accordingly, in claims arising from tortious acts, the court of the place where the tort was committed or where the damage occurred or is likely to occur, or the court of the place of residence of the injured party, has jurisdiction.

 

5- DETERMINING THE AMOUNT OF DAMAGE AND FAULT IN VEHICLE LOSS OF VALUE:

 

An expert report is obtained to determine the parties’ level of fault in the case and the vehicle’s loss of value. The expert report is crucial for the outcome of the case. Damage history and its nature, mileage, make and model information, year of manufacture, market value, and the nature of the damage sustained also play a significant role in determining the compensation amount.

 

6- CAN A LOSS OF VALUE COMPENSATION LAWSUIT BE FILED FOR A VEHICLE THAT HAS BEEN IN A PREVIOUS ACCIDENT?

 

If your vehicle has a damage record from a date prior to the accident, a loss of value lawsuit may be dismissed because the loss of value cannot be attributed solely to this accident and because the vehicle has lost value in a previous accident. Therefore, before filing a lawsuit, it’s important to consider whether the vehicle has a history of accidents and whether parts have been replaced. When determining loss of value, among many other factors, whether the vehicle has been involved in a previous accident is also considered, and the determination of loss of value varies depending on each specific case.

 

7-STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS IN VEHICLE LOSS OF VALUE COMPENSATION LAWSUITS:

THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENTS MUST BE INCLUDED IN THE APPLICATION TO THE INSURANCE ARBITRATION COMMISSION:

 

Application form with a wet signature

A valid identification document (ID card, driver’s license, etc.) from the applicant

A copy of the bank receipt confirming payment of the application fee

A final response letter signed by the insurance company officials indicating that the application was partially or completely rejected, or a document proving that the insurance company did not respond in writing within 15 business days (15 days for traffic insurance) after the application was submitted (notary public notice, registered mail or cargo receipt, a copy of the insurance company’s document registration date).

A statement detailing why the response received from the insurance company did not meet the request and clearly and concretely stating the application to the commission.

For applications made by attorney, a copy of the attorney fee receipt and a bar association stamp.

 

4th Court of Appeals CIVIL DEPARTMENT Decision No. E. 2001/12342, K. 2002/3124, Date: March 18, 2002:

 

“…The case is a claim for compensation arising from a traffic accident, and the court, based on the expert report, has determined that there will be no loss in value in the plaintiff’s vehicle. It must be accepted that the exchange (market) value of the vehicle after repair will be less than its exchange value before the incident. This is because, even if fully repaired, this car will still show signs of damage. Its value in the repaired state, no matter how well repaired, is generally lower than the value of a similar vehicle without any damage, resulting in a loss of its current value… The case is a claim for compensation arising from a traffic accident, and the court, based on the expert report, has determined that there will be no loss in value in the plaintiff’s vehicle… However, if the value of the plaintiff’s assets after the incident is less than what they would have been if the damaging event had not occurred, there is damage. Indeed, something is destroyed. In the event of damage or loss, objective value should be taken as a rule as a basis for determining objective damages. This is the exchange (market) value…”

 

COURT OF APPEALS 17TH CIVIL DIVISION E. 2016/17995 K. 2017/9940

 

November 1, 2017:

…In compensation cases arising from traffic accidents, the party who caused the damage is liable for the actual damages to the extent of their fault. The … company that insured the injured party’s vehicle with compulsory liability insurance is also liable for the actual damages of the injured party, along with the injured party. Even if the damage to the vehicle damaged in the traffic accident is repaired, the loss of value of the vehicle due to the accident is considered within the actual damages, and both the injured party and the … company are liable for this loss.

 

In the present case, the plaintiff’s attorney requested that the defendants recover the loss of value of the vehicle due to the accident. The court ruled that the defendant insurance company was not liable for the loss of value of the vehicle. The case was dismissed for the defendant … Inc. on the grounds that the defendant … Inc. was at fault. The plaintiff did not appeal the decision.

 

For the reasons explained above, … Inc. is liable for the actual damages resulting from the accident up to the maximum policy limit. The loss of value incurred in the vehicle is also a real and direct damage. In this case, while the decision should have been made to determine that the defendant … Inc. is jointly liable for the loss of value expense without issuing an executive order, it is incorrect to dismiss the case for … Inc. and determine that only the defendant … Inc. is liable.

 

COURT OF APPEALS 17TH CIVIL DIVISION E. 2015/6486K. 2017/12264

 

December 28, 2017

…In this case, the court will evaluate the vehicle’s model, make, features, damage, repairs, mileage, age at the time of the incident, the plaintiff’s claims, the defendant’s defenses, and the entire file together, and determine the vehicle’s undamaged second-hand market value before the accident and the value after the accident. and the second-hand market value after repair, the loss of value should be determined according to the difference, and a new report should be prepared that is detailed, reasoned and open to audit in order to eliminate any discrepancies that may arise, and then all the evidence in the file should be evaluated together, a report suitable for auditing and making a judgment should be prepared, and a decision should be made based on the result reached. However, it was not deemed appropriate to make a decision in writing.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir