
Republic of Turkey
COURT OF APPEALS
LAW DEPARTMENT
2016/19373
2017/11054
September 20, 2017
* SIGNING A PROMISE ON BEHALF OF A COMPANY DURING LACK OF REPRESENTATION (Since the debtor acting as an unauthorized representative is personally liable for his signature on behalf of the company/as the drawer of the promissory note, there is no unlawfulness in pursuing a lien on the said bill of exchange through a lien specific to bills of exchange)
* CANCELLATION OF PROCEEDING (According to the response from the Trade Registry Office to the debtor being pursued, the borrower who signed a promissory note on behalf of the drawer company, despite lacking authority to represent, is personally liable for his signature on behalf of the drawer company) Since the debtor acting as an unauthorized representative is liable for the promissory note as the drawer, there is no unlawfulness in pursuing a lien specifically for bills of exchange against the said debtor.
* LEGAL SEIZURE ON BILLS OF EXCHANGE (According to the written response from the Trade Registry Office, the debtor is found not to be a representative of the company. However, the dissenting debtor who signed the promissory note on behalf of the drawer company, despite not having the authority to do so, will be personally liable for his signature on behalf of the company that issued the promissory note.)
6102/Art. 678,778/2
SUMMARY: In the present case, the debtor being pursued by the creditor is found not to be a representative of the company, according to the written response from the Trade Registry Office. In this case, the objecting debtor who signs a promissory note on behalf of the issuing company, despite not having the authority to represent it, will naturally be personally liable for the signature he/she made on behalf of the issuing company. Since the debtor, acting as an unauthorized representative, is liable for the promissory note as the issuer, there is no unlawfulness in pursuing a lien on the aforementioned person, specifically for bills of exchange. Therefore, while the court should have dismissed the objection, its decision to annul the proceedings based on the written justification is inappropriate.
CASE: Upon the creditor’s request for an appeal within the timeframe of the court decision dated and numbered above, the relevant file was sent from the local court to the relevant chamber. After hearing the report prepared by the Investigating Judge for the case file and reviewing all the documents in the file, the matter was discussed and considered:
DECISION: In the proceeding initiated by the creditor through a lien on bills of exchange based on the promissory note, the debtor applied to the enforcement court: It was understood that the court annulled the proceedings against the debtor, claiming that he signed the promissory note on behalf of the company, that he was not personally indebted, and that he had no outstanding debt. The court ruled to annul the proceedings against the debtor on the grounds that the promissory note contained two signatures, both of which were stamped. Therefore, the debtor was not an officer of the company and therefore could not be held personally liable for his signature on the promissory note.
Article 678 of the TCC, which should also apply to promissory notes by reference to Article 778/2, paragraph (e), states: “A person who affixes his signature to a bill of exchange as the representative of another person, although he is not authorized to represent, is personally liable for that bill of exchange…”
In this particular case, the debtor against whom the creditor initiated the proceedings was found not to be a representative of the company, based on the written response from the Trade Registry Office. In this case, the objecting debtor, who signed the promissory note on behalf of the issuing company despite not having the authority to represent, would naturally be personally liable for his signature on behalf of the issuing company. Since the debtor, acting as an unauthorized representative, is liable for the promissory note as the drawer, there is no unlawfulness in pursuing a lien on the aforementioned person, specifically for bills of exchange.
Therefore, while the court should have dismissed the objection, its decision to cancel the proceedings based on the written justification is inappropriate.
RESULT: The creditor’s appeals were accepted, and the court’s decision was REVERSED for the reasons stated above, in accordance with Articles 366 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code and 428 of the Civil Procedure Code. The prepaid fee was refunded upon request, with a 10-day period from the date of service of the judgment for correction.