
What is a Judicial Control Measure? (CMK 109)
A judicial control measure is a measure implemented in lieu of an arrest warrant, placing a suspect or defendant under supervision despite the existence of grounds for arrest. Instead of a detention order, the judge releases the suspect or defendant under supervision “under the condition of judicial control.” Judicial control measures allow the suspect or defendant to be placed under control by a judicial decision, but only through administrative means (such as providing a signature, a travel ban, etc.). Judicial control measures can only be ordered by a criminal court (CMK Article 110).
Judicial control measures can also be applied to crimes for which the Code of Criminal Procedure stipulates a ban on arrest (CMK Article 100/4), that is, crimes carrying a maximum prison sentence of less than two years.
Arrest is the most severe criminal measure applied to a person suspected of a crime. Judicial control measures are designed to prevent certain disadvantages of detention and are an alternative method aimed at controlling the suspect or defendant within their social life. Furthermore, provisions regarding judicial control may also apply to those released due to the expiration of their legally mandated detention periods.
Judicial control and probation should not be confused. Probation is applied during the execution phase of a final sentence. Judicial control measures, on the other hand, are implemented while the trial is ongoing, meaning at a stage where the sentence has not yet been finalized. Although probation and judicial control are separate institutions, they are overseen by the Probation Directorate, leading to confusion between the concepts in practice.
Petition to Appeal Against the Judicial Control Decision
.……. TO THE CRIMINAL COURT JUDGE
SUSPECT:
TR IDENTITY NUMBER:
ADDRESS:
DEFENDER:
ADDRESS:
CHARGED CRIME: Theft
DATE OF JUDICIAL CONTROL
DECISION ISSUED: …/…/…
SUBJECT: Objection to the Judicial Control Decision.
EXPLANATIONS:
1-) A lawsuit was filed against our client on …/…/… with the …… Criminal Court, under file number …/… E. …/… K., for allegedly committing a theft at the home of the complainant …. on …/…/…. As a result of this case, following his arrest by decision of the local court on …/…/…, the request for his release pending investigation was rejected by ………. Following the appeal of the Criminal Court’s decision, the suspect was released. It was subsequently ordered that the suspect be placed under judicial control, subject to the request to apply and sign at the police station closest to his residence, once a week on Mondays during business hours, in accordance with Law No. 5271. (Annex 1)
2-) Our client has just turned 19 and lives with his elderly mother, who requires care. (Annex 2) The family’s economic situation is extremely poor, and the mother is unable to contribute to the household income, leaving him financially dependent on our client.
3-) For the reasons explained above, our client’s application to the police station closest to his residence during business hours on weekdays and signing would result in far greater harm than the anticipated benefit. Our client has also struggled to find his current job, and this situation could disrupt and possibly even lead to the loss of his job. For the reasons we have explained, we are objecting to the judicial control decision issued against our client.
LEGAL REASONS: Articles 101, 105, and 115 of Law No. 5271.
CONCLUSION AND REQUEST: For the reasons explained above, we are objecting to the judicial control decision issued against our client and requesting that your Supreme Court accept our objection. …/…/…
ATTACHMENTS: 1-…. Criminal Court file and copy of the judicial control decision
2- Residence document
3- One certified copy of a power of attorney
Suspect’s Attorney
Attorney