Anasayfa » Blog » Can a Worker Be Dismissed Without Compensation?

Can a Worker Be Dismissed Without Compensation?

The emergence of justifiable grounds for the employer to dismiss an employee and not pay compensation does not automatically terminate the employment contract. Dismissal by the employer (termination of the employment contract for just cause) terminates the contract by a unilateral declaration of intent. The party in whose favor this right arises (employee or employer) must exercise this right. The party wishing to exercise this right must provide written notice of termination and clearly state the reason for termination.

 

The grounds for dismissing an employee without compensation (termination for just cause) regulated by law are as follows:

 

DISmissing an Employee Without Compensation Due to Health Reasons

Illness or injury caused by the employee’s own fault is regulated under the heading of health reasons. Accordingly, if an employee suffers an illness or injury resulting from their own intentional behavior, their disorderly lifestyle, or their addiction to alcohol, and if the resulting absence lasts more than three consecutive workdays or five workdays in a month. A fondness for nightlife can be an example of a lack of regularity.

 

An employee contracting an incurable illness is a health reason. The Health Board must prove that the employee’s incurable illness impedes their ability to work at the workplace. In this case, the employee’s fault will not be considered.

 

An employee suffering from an illness, accident, childbirth, or pregnancy without fault is a final health reason. If an employee, despite being at fault, experiences an illness, accident, pregnancy, or childbirth, the employer’s right to terminate arises after the notification periods specified in Law 17 exceed six weeks of the employee’s length of service at the workplace. In the case of childbirth or pregnancy, this period begins after the expiration of the 16-week legally mandated periods.

 

DISMISSAL OF AN EMPLOYEE WITHOUT COMPENSATION DUE TO VIOLATION OF ETHICS AND GOOD FAITH

An employee’s fraudulent behavior constitutes a violation of ethics and good faith. If an employee claims to possess qualifications they did not possess at the time the employment contract was established, or misleads the employer by providing false information, this constitutes just cause for termination for the employer. This misrepresentation must be based on fundamental principles of the contract. The fraud must be committed for the purpose of establishing the contract.

 

An employee’s words or actions that harm the employer’s honor and dignity are considered unethical. If an employee speaks or acts against the employer’s family, as well as words or actions that harm the employer’s honor and dignity, or makes false reports or accusations against the employer, this constitutes just cause for termination.

 

Sexual harassment by an employee of another employee constitutes just cause for termination due to a violation of ethics. The harassment does not necessarily occur in the workplace. Even if it occurs outside the workplace, it is a justifiable ground for termination, as it disrupts order.

 

An employee’s bullying of the employer or alcohol abuse is also a ground for termination due to a violation of the rules of ethics and good faith. If the employee bullies the employer, a family member, or another employee, the employer may terminate the employment contract without notice. The Turkish Penal Code (TCK) requirements for bullying are not required. The bullying must be committed by the employee directly. Bullying of the employee’s family does not constitute justifiable grounds for termination. For example, swearing constitutes bullying. Furthermore, if the employee arrives at work drunk or under the influence of drugs, or uses these substances at work, it is a justifiable ground for termination.

 

An employee’s behavior that violates integrity and loyalty is also a ground for termination. Accordingly, the employee must engage in behavior that violates integrity and loyalty, such as abusing the employer’s trust, stealing, or revealing the employer’s professional secrets. This is a violation of the rules of ethics and good faith. These situations are not limited in scope; examples are provided. For example, a guard sleeping while on duty is considered unethical. In these cases, a breach of duty of loyalty is often also involved.

 

An employee’s committing a crime at work is also contrary to the principles of morality and good faith. Therefore, for justified termination, the employee must commit a crime punishable by more than seven days in prison at the workplace, with a non-deferred sentence. The employee must commit the crime at the workplace where they are performing their work. This provision does not apply if the penalty for the crime is a judicial fine.

 

An employee’s absenteeism is also contrary to the principles of morality and good faith. If an employee is absent for two consecutive workdays, or two consecutive workdays within a month, or three workdays within a month, without permission from the employer or justifiable cause, this constitutes justifiable termination for the employer. The goal is to maintain the stability of the work schedule and ensure the continuous operation of the job. If the employee is absent for reasons such as a child’s illness or testifying, the employee is deemed to have justifiable cause. Even if the employee has a justifiable cause, they must notify the employer.

However, if the employee cannot be expected to provide notice in accordance with the principle of honesty, failure to provide notice cannot be considered grounds for termination by the employer for just cause.

 

An employee’s failure to perform their job duties also constitutes a violation of the rules of ethics and good faith. If an employee persists in not performing their assigned duties despite being reminded, this constitutes grounds for termination for just cause for the employer. The employer must prove that the employee was reminded of their duties. Therefore, a written reminder is beneficial.

 

Endangering occupational safety and causing harm to the employer is also a violation of the rules of good faith. The HR Authority has defined situations where an employee endangers workplace safety, whether through their own will or negligence, or causes damage or loss to machinery, equipment, or other items and materials within their possession, whether property of the workplace or not, to the extent that they cannot pay thirty days’ wages. This violates the duty of care. While the employee must be at fault, this behavior does not necessarily result in damage.

 

Another reason is the emergence of a compelling reason that prevents the employee from working at the workplace for more than a week. If this reason occurs, the employee is paid half wages for each day during the one-week waiting period. At the end of this waiting period, the employer is free to terminate the contract without notice. If the employer does not terminate the employment contract at the end of this period, the employment contract remains suspended.

 

IF THE EMPLOYEE IS DETAINED OR ARREST AND THEIR ABSENCE EXCEEDS THE NOTIFICATION PERIOD SET FORTH IN ARTICLE 17, IT IS GROUNDBITE OF TERMINATION FOR JUSTIFIED CAUSE FOR THE EMPLOYER. THESE NOTIFICATION PERIODS ARE:

a) 2 weeks for employees with 0-6 months of seniority,

 

b) 4 weeks for employees with 6 months to 1.5 years of seniority,

 

c) 6 weeks for employees with 1.5 years to 3 years of seniority,

 

d) 8 weeks for employees with more than 3 years of seniority.

 

These periods do not apply if the employer terminates the employment contract immediately (without notice) for just cause, as specified above.

 

HOW CAN AN EMPLOYEE BE DISMISSED WITHOUT COMPENSATION?

An employer who wishes to terminate an employment contract for the reasons mentioned above must submit a termination statement. The Supreme Court of Appeals has held that this statement must be in writing. The statement must state the reason for termination. An employer who wishes to terminate based on circumstances that violate the rules of ethics and good faith, or similar circumstances, must submit a termination statement to the other party within 6 business days of learning of the incident, and in all likelihood, within 1 year of the date of the incident. These periods are statute of limitations. However, if the worker gains financial benefit from the incident, the one-year period does not apply.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir