Anasayfa » Blog » Sample Decision On The Method Of Notification Of Tax Documents

Sample Decision On The Method Of Notification Of Tax Documents

Sample Decision On The Method Of Notification Of Tax Documents

Council of State 3rd Chamber Presidency 2017/2459 E. , 2021/720 K.

“Case Law Text”

T.C.

COUNCIL OF STATE

THIRD CHAMBER

Case No: 2017/2459

Decision No: 2021/720

APPELLANT (DEFENDANT): … Tax Office Directorate/…

ATTORNEY: Attorney …

OPPOSING PARTY (PLAINTIFF): … Construction, Food, Textile, and Livestock Industry Trade Limited Company

SUBJECT OF THE REQUEST: It is requested that the decision of the … Regional Administrative Court … Tax Litigation Chamber dated … and numbered E:…, K:… regarding the appeal against the decision of the … Tax Court dated … and numbered E:…, K:… be reviewed on appeal and overturned.

JUDICIAL PROCESS:

Subject matter of the case: The case concerns the plaintiff’s request for the cancellation of the payment order dated … and numbered …, issued for the collection of various public debts for the year 2010.

Summary of the First Instance Court’s decision: Since the notices of tax and penalties on which the payment order in question is based could not be found at the plaintiff’s address, it was ruled that the payment order was served by having it signed by the neighborhood headman and affixing a notice to the door, in accordance with Article 21 of the Notification Law No. 7201, without complying with the provisions on notification in the Tax Procedure Law No. 213. , by having it signed by the neighborhood headman and affixing a notice to the door. Therefore, the payment order was canceled on the grounds that there was no proper notification and that the public debt was not finalized.

Summary of the Regional Administrative Court’s decision: The appeal was rejected pursuant to Article 45, paragraph 3, of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 on the grounds that it was not deemed to be of a nature that would lead to the revocation of the Tax Court’s decision, which was found to be in accordance with the procedure and the law.

CLAIMS OF THE APPELLANT: The grounds that could be raised in a lawsuit against the payment order are limited to those listed in Article 58 of Law No. 6183 on the Collection Procedures for Public Receivables, namely: that there is no such debt, that it has been partially paid, and that it is time-barred, and that the claims made by the plaintiff do not fall within this scope, requesting that the decision be overturned.

DEFENSE OF THE OTHER PARTY: No defense was submitted.

OPINION OF THE COUNCIL OF STATE INVESTIGATING JUDGE …: It is considered that the appeal should be rejected and the decision upheld.

IN THE NAME OF THE TURKISH NATION

After hearing the explanations of the Investigating Judge and examining the documents in the file, the Third Chamber of the Council of State, which rendered the decision, deliberated as follows:

LEGAL ASSESSMENT:

The final decisions of regional administrative courts may be overturned on appeal only if one of the reasons specified in Article 49 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 exists.

The decision reviewed on appeal is in accordance with the procedure and the law, and the grounds for appeal put forward in the petition are not considered to warrant the reversal of the decision.

CONCLUSION:

For the reasons stated above;

1. The appeal request is rejected.

2. The decision of the … Tax Litigation Chamber of the … Regional Administrative Court dated … and numbered E:…, K:… is CONFIRMED. 3. Pursuant to Article 50 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, the file shall be sent to the court of first instance that issued the decision to ensure that the decision is notified to the parties and a copy is sent to the specified Tax Litigation Chamber. It was unanimously and definitively decided on 09/02/2021.

 

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir