Events
The applicant was detained as part of an investigation conducted by the prosecutor general’s office; he was released on condition of judicial control by a decision of the magistrate’s office.
A public lawsuit has been filed by the Prosecutor General’s office in the heavy criminal court with a request to punish the applicant by betting that the applicant has committed a crime of child sexual abuse.
The applicant requested the abolition of the judicial control measure imposed on him; the heavy criminal court decided to abolish the judicial control measure applied against the applicant and acquit the applicant of the crime committed on him. The appeal against this decision was rejected and the acquittal was finalized.
The applicant is subject to Article 141 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271. according to the article, he filed a lawsuit with a claim for financial and non-pecuniary damages of 20,000 TL and 40,000 TL due to unjustified detention and a judicial control measure.
As a result of the trial, the court of first instance decided that the material compensation of 31.63 TL and the moral compensation of 1.000 TL should be given to the applicant together with the legal interest to be operated from the date of detention, as well as the payment of the power of attorney fee of 4.360 TL.
An appeal has been filed against this decision. The district court of justice has decided to reject the applications for the part related to material compensation on the basis of the appeal, and the application for the part related to non-pecuniary compensation has been corrected and rejected on the basis of the application.
Claims
The applicant claimed that his right to a fair trial was violated due to the fact that the claim for compensation based on the judicial control measure was not evaluated, and the right to travel was also violated due to the provision of the judicial control measure.
Evaluation Of The Court
Article 36 of the Constitution. the right to a fair trial guaranteed in the article is applied not only in trials related to criminal charges, but also in trials related to the determination of a person’s civil rights and obligations. Rights and privileges granted to persons by law and having a defensible basis are also included in the concept of rights.
In the earlier decision of the Constitutional Court to demand compensation control named because the degree of violation of the right to a reasoned decision by the court had concluded that were not met; named after reviewing numerous references on the same subject of the request for compensation due to control measures by addressing whether recognized by the Turkish law has heard.
There is no doubt that there is no trial related to the criminal charge in the concrete dispute. However, it is necessary to determine whether the dispute can be considered within the scope of civil rights and obligations by its nature, and in this context, first of all, whether there is a right recognized by law or case law in the middle. In this regard, it should be clarified whether the right to compensation is recognized by law or case law due to the application of a judicial control measure in Turkish law.
In the Law No. 5271, which is the basic legal regulation on the subject of the dispute, it is clearly stated under what conditions compensation will be provided. There is no regulation in this Law regarding judicial control decisions made in violation of the law.
In addition to the fact that a civil right of a defensible nature that is clearly recognized by law is not accepted, the practice and practice of the competent judicial authorities should also be evaluated regarding the existence of this right in order to determine whether such a right exists.
In the Supreme Court decision submitted by the applicant, it was understood that the content and duration of the judicial control decision led to an application that could lead to the result of deprivation of liberty of persons such as arrest, and the Supreme Court accepted that the application of the judicial control decision in question was not proportionate. It has been observed that in cases where similar claims have been made, no determination has been reached as in the Supreme Court’s decision, but rather that cases filed due to judicial control measures other than this exceptional decision should be dismissed due to the lack of explicit regulation in Law No. 5271 continue to be settled case law.
In the face of this situation, it has been determined that the concrete material conditions and the results of the judicial practice shown by the applicant as the basis for the alleged matters are different from each other.
After all these explanations, the applicant’s claim for damages in the absence of a clear legal basis, in other words, right in the middle by law, explicitly or implicitly, that we cannot talk about the existence of an accepted judicial practice was to form the basis will give way to the demands of determination cannot be made or that were evaluated.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the claim that the right to a fair trial has been violated on the grounds described is inadmissible due to lack of authority in terms of the issue.
The applicant also claimed that his freedom of travel had been violated due to the provision of a judicial control measure.
Article 148 of the Constitution. article 45 of the Law on the Establishment and Judicial Procedures of the Constitutional Court No. 6216 with the third paragraph of its article. according to October article, in order to examine an individual application, the right allegedly violated by public power must be guaranteed in the Constitution, as well as fall under the scope of additional protocols to the European Convention on Human Rights (the Convention) and the Convention to which Turkey is a party. Applications containing an alleged violation of rights that fall outside the common protection area of the Constitution and the Convention are not covered by the individual application.
Article 23 of the Constitution. and October 2 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention. in its article, there is freedom of travel within the country, as well as freedom of departure from the country where people are located. However, since Turkey is not a party to the aforementioned Protocol, Article 23 of the Constitution. applications for freedom of travel contained in the article are not covered by an individual application.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the claim that the freedom of travel has been violated on the grounds described is inadmissible due to lack of authority in terms of the issue.