Anasayfa » Blog » The Competent Court in Disputes Arising from Diagnostic and Treatment Services—Supreme Court Decision

The Competent Court in Disputes Arising from Diagnostic and Treatment Services—Supreme Court Decision

Petition Of Appeal Against Forced Detention

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE COURT OF CASSATION
13th Civil Chamber Case No.: 2012/21184
Decision No.: 2012/20509
Date of Decision: 28 September 2012

ACTION FOR ANNULMENT OF OBJECTION – UPON EVALUATION OF THE SPECIFIC CASE, IT IS UNDERSTOOD THAT THE DISPUTE BETWEEN THE PARTIES ARISES FROM DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT SERVICES – IT IS UNDERSTOOD THAT THE PLAINTIFFS ARE CONSUMERS AND THE DEFENDANT IS THE SELLER AS DEFINED BY LAW – THE JUDGMENT MUST BE REVERSED

SUMMARY: In order for a legal transaction to be deemed to fall within the scope of Law No. 4077, there must be a legal transaction concerning the sale of goods and services between the parties whose definitions are provided within the purpose of the Law. Article 23 of Law No. 4077 provides that all disputes concerning the application of this Law shall be heard by Consumer Courts. Upon evaluation of the specific case, it is understood that the dispute between the parties arises from diagnosis and treatment services, and that the plaintiffs are consumers (purchasers of treatment services) and the defendant is the seller (service provider) as defined by the Law. Accordingly, the court having jurisdiction over the action is the Consumer Court, not the General Court. Provisions concerning jurisdiction are matters of public order and shall be taken into consideration ex officio at every stage of the proceedings, even if not raised by the parties. No vested right may arise in matters concerning jurisdiction. Therefore, the court should have rendered a decision of lack of jurisdiction.

(Law No. 4077, Arts. 1, 2, 3, 23) (Law No. 818, Arts. 41, 47)

Action: Upon the appeal by the parties’ attorneys, within the prescribed period, against the judgment rendered at the conclusion of the proceedings concerning the action for annulment of objection between the parties, whereby the action was partially accepted and partially dismissed for the reasons stated in the judgment, the file was examined and the matter was discussed and considered as necessary:

Decision: Counsel for the plaintiffs alleged that the plaintiff K.İ. was examined by the other defendant physician at the hospital owned by the defendant company due to lower back pain and that treatment was initiated; however, due to failure to make the correct diagnosis in a timely manner and the application of incorrect treatment, the plaintiff subsequently underwent stem cell treatment and chemotherapy at another hospital, and suffered pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. Accordingly, they requested the collection of TRY 1,000 in pecuniary damages and TRY 300,000 in non-pecuniary damages, without prejudice to their rights regarding the excess amount, and by their amendment petition, they increased their claim for pecuniary damages to TRY 400,000.

The defendants requested dismissal of the action.

The Court ruled that TRY 34,586.84 in pecuniary damages and TRY 75,000 in non-pecuniary damages for the plaintiff K.İ., and TRY 25,000 in non-pecuniary damages for M.İ., be collected from the defendants in proportion to their respective degrees of fault. The judgment was appealed by the parties.

1- Article 1, titled “Purpose,” of the Consumer Protection Law No. 4077, as amended by Law No. 4822, sets forth the purpose of the Law, while Article 2, titled “Scope,” contains the relevant provision. Article 3 of the Law defines “goods” as movable property subject to purchase and sale, immovable property intended for residential and vacation purposes, and software, audio, visual and similar intangible goods prepared for use in an electronic environment; “service” as any activity other than the provision of goods performed in return for a fee or benefit; “seller” as natural or legal persons, including public legal entities, who offer goods to consumers within the scope of their commercial or professional activities; and “consumer” as a natural or legal person who acquires, uses or benefits from a good or service for purposes that are not commercial or professional.

Likewise, Article 3/d of the aforementioned Law defines it as follows.

In order for a legal transaction to be deemed to fall within the scope of Law No. 4077, there must be a legal transaction concerning the sale of goods and services between the parties whose definitions are provided above within the purpose of the Law. Article 23 of Law No. 4077 provides that all disputes concerning the application of this Law shall be heard by Consumer Courts.

Upon evaluation of the specific case, it is understood that the dispute between the parties arises from diagnosis and treatment services, and that the plaintiffs are consumers (purchasers of treatment services) and the defendant is the seller (service provider) as defined by the Law. Accordingly, the court having jurisdiction over the action is the Consumer Court, not the General Court. Provisions concerning jurisdiction are matters of public order and shall be taken into consideration ex officio at every stage of the proceedings, even if not raised by the parties. No vested right may arise in matters concerning jurisdiction. Therefore, although the court should have rendered a decision of lack of jurisdiction, entering into the merits of the action and rendering a judgment was contrary to procedural law and the law and constitutes a ground for reversal.

2- In view of the ground for reversal, there is no need at this stage to examine the parties’ other grounds of appeal.

Conclusion: For the reasons explained in paragraph one, the appealed judgment is hereby REVERSED; for the reasons explained in paragraph two, there is no need to examine the parties’ other grounds of appeal; the advance appeal fee of TRY 1.99 paid by each party shall, upon request, be refunded to the defendants; and the advance appeal fee of TRY 21.15 shall, upon request, be refunded to the plaintiffs. It was unanimously decided on 28 September 2012.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir