Anasayfa » Blog » Supreme Court Ruling: A Bond Held at a Bank May Be Canceled Due to Loss

Supreme Court Ruling: A Bond Held at a Bank May Be Canceled Due to Loss

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
COURT OF CASSATION
11th CIVIL CHAMBER

FILE NO.: 2016/9880
DECISION NO.: 2018/2363
DATE OF DECISION: 03.04.2018

LOSS OF A PROMISSORY NOTE HELD BY A BANK – THE BANK HAS A LEGAL INTEREST IN SEEKING THE CANCELLATION OF THE PROMISSORY NOTE DUE TO LOSS

SUMMARY: The action concerns a request for the cancellation of promissory notes due to their loss, and the Court dismissed the action on the ground that the claimant had no legal interest in bringing the action, as set forth in its judgment. However, it is understood from the contents of the file that the claimant bank had acquired the promissory notes for which cancellation was sought by way of a collection endorsement and therefore had the status of an authorized holder. Since a collection endorsement is a form of representation authority specific to negotiable instruments, intended to collect the amount of the instrument and to perform protective acts relating to the rights arising therefrom, a bank acting as an authorized holder has the right to request the return of an instrument held by a third party or to seek its cancellation due to loss. Accordingly, the Court should have rendered its decision by taking into consideration that the claimant had a legal interest in bringing an action for the cancellation of the negotiable instruments.

In the action heard without any opposing party, the judgment rendered by the Malatya 4th Civil Court of First Instance dated 08/01/2016 and numbered 2015/485-2016/42 was appealed for review by the claimant’s attorney. Upon determining that the appeal petition had been submitted within the prescribed period, the report prepared by Reviewing Judge Özlem Ezgi Solak concerning the case file was heard, and after reading and examining the petitions, pleadings, hearing minutes, and all documents contained in the file, the matter was duly considered and deliberated:

The claimant’s attorney alleged that the negotiable instruments delivered to his client by way of collection endorsement had been lost at the claimant’s branches and requested and brought an action for the cancellation of the negotiable instruments.

Based on the entire contents of the file, the Court dismissed the action on the ground that actions for the cancellation of negotiable instruments must be brought by the authorized holder and that the claimant bank, which held the instruments by way of collection endorsement, had no legal interest.

The judgment was appealed by the claimant’s attorney.

The action concerns a request for the cancellation of promissory notes due to their loss, and the Court dismissed the action on the ground that the claimant had no legal interest, as set forth in its judgment. However, it is understood from the contents of the file that the claimant bank had acquired the promissory notes for which cancellation was sought by way of a collection endorsement and therefore had the status of an authorized holder. Since a collection endorsement is a form of representation authority specific to negotiable instruments, intended to collect the amount of the instrument and to perform protective acts relating to the rights arising therefrom, a bank acting as an authorized holder has the right to request the return of an instrument held by a third party or to seek its cancellation due to loss. Accordingly, the Court should have taken into consideration that the claimant had a legal interest in bringing an action for the cancellation of the negotiable instruments. Therefore, the dismissal of the action in the manner set forth above was improper, and the judgment was required to be reversed.

CONCLUSION: For the reasons explained above, the appeal objections of the claimant’s attorney are hereby accepted, and the judgment is REVERSED in favor of the claimant. Upon request, the advance appeal fee paid by the appellant shall be refunded. It was unanimously decided on 03/04/2018.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir