Anasayfa » Blog » Wire Transfer Without a Description, Wire Transfer Without a Remarks Field, Claim That the Payment Relates to Another Business Transaction, Burden of Proof, Supreme Court Decision

Wire Transfer Without a Description, Wire Transfer Without a Remarks Field, Claim That the Payment Relates to Another Business Transaction, Burden of Proof, Supreme Court Decision

Joint Custody And Its Scope

Summary:

The Court had an expert examination conducted. The expert determined that a total of TRY 13,200 had been transferred without any explanation from the account held by the defendant tenant at the Y. Erzurum Ziraat Bank branch to the Akbank account belonging to the claimant. At the hearing dated 20.01.2015, the claimant’s attorney stated that these payments had not been made against the rent debt and that they had been made for another commercial transaction. At the same hearing, the defendants’ attorney argued that there was no other legal relationship between the parties and that TRY 12,000 had been paid as one year’s rent and TRY 1,200 as a security deposit.

Although the claimant landlord argued that there was another legal relationship between the parties and that these payments had not been made against the rent debt, the burden of proving the existence of another legal relationship rests with the claimant landlord. In this situation, the Court should have considered that the burden of proving that the payments in question were made on the basis of another legal relationship rested with the claimant, and should have rendered its decision accordingly. Therefore, the judgment rendered on the basis of an incomplete examination was not proper.


REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE
COURT OF CASSATION
6th CIVIL CHAMBER

File No.: 2015/5808
Decision No.: 2016/1336
Date of Decision: 25.2.2016

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE: Civil Court of Peace
TYPE OF ACTION: Action for Annulment of Objection

The judgment rendered by the local court in the action for annulment of objection, the date and number of which are indicated above, was appealed by the defendants within the prescribed period. Having read all documents contained in the file, the matter was duly considered and deliberated.

The action concerns a request for the annulment of the objection made to enforcement proceedings initiated for the collection of rent receivables. Upon the Court’s acceptance of the action, the judgment was appealed by the defendants’ attorney.

In the statement of claim, the claimant’s attorney stated that, because the defendants had failed to pay seven months’ rent calculated at TRY 1,000 per month, they had unjustly objected to the enforcement proceedings initiated against them for the collection of the rent receivable, and requested the annulment of the defendants’ objection. The defendants’ attorney argued that the rent had been paid through the … branch and requested dismissal of the action. The Court accepted the action on the ground that there was no credit entry in the bank account held in the claimant’s name.

There is no dispute between the parties regarding the existence of the one-year lease agreement commencing on 04.02.2013 and signed between them. Under the agreement, the monthly rent was determined as TRY 1,000. Relying on this lease agreement, the claimant landlord initiated enforcement proceedings against the defendants on 12.05.2014 and sought collection of a total rent receivable of TRY 7,000, calculated at TRY 1,000 per month for the rent due from February through August 2013. In their timely objections, the defendants disputed the entire debt, asserting that the rent had been paid into the bank.

The Court had an expert examination conducted. The expert determined that TRY 13,200 had been transferred without any explanation from the account held by the defendant tenant at the … branch to the … account belonging to the claimant. At the hearing dated 20.01.2015, the claimant’s attorney stated that these payments had not been made against the rent debt and that they had been made for another commercial transaction. At the same hearing, the defendants’ attorney argued that there was no other legal relationship between the parties and that TRY 12,000 had been paid as one year’s rent and TRY 1,200 as a security deposit.

Although the Court examined the bank receipts that were the subject of the action, corresponded with …, and accepted the action on the ground that the account did not belong to the claimant, it was established that the account in question belonged to the tenant; that payments had been made from this account to the claimant’s account; that the payments were made in the amounts of TRY 1,200 on 07.06.2013, TRY 5,000 on 18.06.2013, TRY 3,500 on 05.07.2013, and TRY 3,500 on 16.08.2013; that the bank receipts contained no explanation; and that the claimant had acknowledged these payments but alleged that they had been made in connection with another legal relationship.

The claimant sought, through the enforcement proceedings, payment of the rent for the first seven months from the commencement of the lease agreement, while the defendants had made a payment of TRY 13,200 to the claimant through a bank.

Although the claimant landlord argued that there was another legal relationship between the parties and therefore that these payments had not been made against the rent debt, the burden of proving the existence of another legal relationship rests with the claimant landlord. In this situation, the Court should have considered that the burden of proving that the payments in question were made on the basis of another legal relationship rested with the claimant and should have rendered its decision accordingly. Therefore, it was not proper to render a judgment on the basis of an incomplete examination in the manner set forth above.

The judgment must therefore be reversed for this reason.

CONCLUSION: For the reasons explained above, the appeal objections are accepted and, pursuant to Article 428 of the Code of Civil Procedure, taking into consideration the provision of Provisional Article 3 added to the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 by Law No. 6217, the judgment is hereby REVERSED. Upon request, the advance appeal fee shall be refunded to the appellants. It was unanimously decided on 25.02.2016.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir