
5th Criminal Chamber
2018/1826 E., 2018/1439 K.
“Case Law Text”
Following the decision of the Mut Magistrates’ Court of First Instance dated 18/05/2017 and numbered 2017/211 Miscellaneous Case, rejecting the request for termination of the pregnancy of the victim …, who was determined by a medical report to be 10 weeks and 3 days pregnant, within the scope of Investigation No. 2017/926 conducted by the Mut Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office for the offenses of qualified sexual abuse of a child and sexual intercourse with a minor; and following the same Court’s decision dated 25/05/2017 and numbered 2017/219 Miscellaneous Case, rejecting the renewed request; thereafter, following the decision of the same Court dated 16/06/2017 and numbered 2017/261 Miscellaneous Case, rejecting the objection filed against the decision rejecting the same request, on the grounds that the request did not constitute an investigative act and that the Public Prosecutor was required to submit the request for permission to the competent Magistrates’ Court of First Instance; and following the decision of the Silifke Magistrates’ Court of First Instance dated 24/06/2017 and numbered 2017/1301 Miscellaneous Case, rejecting the objection on the grounds that the Public Prosecutor was required to submit the request for permission to the competent Civil Court of First Instance; and following the decision of the Mut Civil Court of First Instance dated 30/06/2017 and numbered 2017/23 Miscellaneous Case, dismissing the matter for lack of jurisdiction on the grounds that the request concerning termination of the pregnancy fell within the jurisdiction of the Magistrates’ Court of First Instance and ordering that the case file be sent to the competent and authorized Mut Magistrates’ Court of First Instance; and thereafter, following the decision of the Mut Magistrates’ Court of First Instance dated 10/07/2017 and numbered 2017/316 Miscellaneous Case, ruling that there was no need to render a decision on the ground that the said request had previously been considered;
Having regard to the following provisions:
Article 99 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, entitled “Termination of Pregnancy,” which provides:
“(1) A person who causes a woman to terminate her pregnancy without her consent shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of five to ten years.
(2) Even with consent, a person who causes a woman whose pregnancy is more than ten weeks to terminate her pregnancy in the absence of a medical necessity shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of two to four years. In such a case, the woman who consents to the termination of her pregnancy shall be sentenced to imprisonment for up to one year or a judicial fine.
(3) If the act specified in the first paragraph causes harm to the woman’s physical or mental health, the person shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of six to twelve years; if the act causes the death of the woman, the person shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of fifteen to twenty years.
(4) If the act specified in the second paragraph causes harm to the woman’s physical or mental health, the person shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of three to six years; if the act causes the death of the woman, the person shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of four to eight years.
(5) Even with consent, where the pregnancy of a woman who has not completed ten weeks is terminated by an unauthorized person, the person shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of two to four years. If the other acts defined in the above paragraphs are committed by an unauthorized person, the sentence to be imposed pursuant to those paragraphs shall be increased by one-half.
(6) If a woman becomes pregnant as a result of a crime of which she is the victim, no penalty shall be imposed on the person who terminates the pregnancy, provided that the pregnancy does not exceed twenty weeks and the woman consents. However, for this purpose, the pregnancy must be terminated by specialist physicians in a hospital setting.”
Article 5 of Law No. 2827 on Population Planning, entitled “Termination of Pregnancy,” which provides:
“Until the completion of the tenth week of pregnancy, the uterus shall be evacuated upon request provided that there is no medical contraindication in terms of the mother’s health.
If the pregnancy exceeds ten weeks, the uterus shall only be evacuated where the pregnancy threatens or will threaten the life of the mother or where it will cause severe disability to the child to be born or to the subsequent generations, on the basis of reasoned reports based on objective findings issued by a specialist in obstetrics and gynecology and a specialist in the relevant field.
In emergency situations threatening life or one of the vital organs where intervention is required immediately, the necessary intervention shall be performed and the uterus evacuated by the authorized physician who determines the condition. However, before performing this intervention, or, where this is not possible, within twenty-four hours at the latest following the intervention, the physician shall be obliged to notify the identity of the woman on whom the intervention was performed, the intervention carried out, and the reasons necessitating the intervention to the provincial health and social assistance directorates in provinces and to the government medical offices in districts.
The nature of emergency intervention situations, the form and substance of the notification to be made, the form of the consent document to be requested from persons consenting to sterilization and evacuation of the uterus, the principles governing its completion, the places where these procedures shall be performed, the health and other conditions required to be present at such places, and matters relating to the inspection and supervision of such places shall be specified in the regulation to be issued.”
Article 6 of Law No. 2827, entitled “Permission for Termination of Pregnancy,” which provides:
“The intervention specified in Article 5 is subject to the consent of the pregnant woman; in the case of minors, to the minor’s consent together with the consent of the parent; and in the case of persons under guardianship who are not of legal age or do not have legal capacity, to the consent of the minor person and the guardian together with the permission of the Magistrates’ Court of First Instance. However, the consent of a pregnant woman who, due to mental incapacity, does not possess freedom of consciousness shall not be required for evacuation of the uterus.
If the persons whose consent is required under the second paragraph of Article 4 and the first paragraph of Article 5 are married, the consent of the spouse shall also be required for sterilization or evacuation of the uterus.
In emergency situations threatening life or one of the vital organs, where obtaining permission from the parent or the Magistrates’ Court would require time and immediate intervention is necessary, the requirement for permission shall not apply.”
In consideration of the foregoing provisions;
Within the scope of Investigation No. 2017/926 conducted by the Mut Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office concerning the alleged offenses of qualified sexual abuse of a child and sexual intercourse with a minor committed against the minor victim …, the Forensic Medicine Department of the Department of Internal Medicine of the Faculty of Medicine of … University issued a Forensic Report dated 09/06/2017 and numbered 72846809/439708, which stated the following opinion:
“… As a result of the examination conducted at the Department of Child Psychiatry, it was learned from the history obtained that she became pregnant for 12 weeks and 6 days as a result of sexual abuse, and considering that the pregnancy resulted from abuse, that the mother was of a young age, and that the mother was undergoing a psychologically traumatic process, termination of the pregnancy would be in the medical interest of both the mother and the fetus (baby) …”
Thereafter, in the petition submitted by the victim and her mother and father to the Mut Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office on 15/06/2017, a request was made for permission to undergo an abortion.
In view of the foregoing, it was considered that the authority to assess the request for termination of the pregnancy in question under the aforementioned legislation fell within the jurisdiction of the Magistrates’ Court of First Instance. Accordingly, with respect to the objection filed against the decision of the Mut Magistrates’ Court of First Instance dated 16/06/2017 and numbered 2017/261 Miscellaneous Case, rejecting the request for termination of the pregnancy in question, the objection should have been examined on its merits. Therefore, it was deemed inappropriate to reject the objection on the grounds that the request did not constitute an investigative act and that the Public Prosecutor was required to submit the request for permission to the competent Civil Court of First Instance, which was considered to be, in substance, a decision of lack of jurisdiction.
Accordingly, upon the notification of the Court of Cassation Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office, together with the case file and the indictment, concerning the request for reversal in the interest of law pursuant to Article 309 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, based on the request of the General Directorate of Criminal Affairs of the Ministry of Justice, expressed in its letter dated 19/01/2018 and numbered 94660652-105-33-8579-2017-Kyb, the matter was considered:
Considering that Article 5/1-d of the Child Protection Law No. 5395, concerning protective and supportive measures, provides that a “health measure” consists of “temporary or continuous medical care and rehabilitation necessary for the protection and treatment of the child’s physical and mental health, and the treatment of persons using addictive substances,” and that the implementation of this measure during an investigation also falls within the jurisdiction of the Magistrates’ Court of First Instance, the contents of the notification based on the request for reversal in the interest of law were found to be well-founded, as the request should be assessed within the scope of a health measure.
Therefore, the request was ACCEPTED, and the decision of the Silifke Magistrates’ Court of First Instance dated 24/06/2017 and numbered 2017/1301 Miscellaneous Case was REVERSED pursuant to Article 309 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271.
In view of the ground for reversal, it was decided that the subsequent proceedings be carried out by the competent authority, and the case file was REFERRED to the Court of Cassation Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office for transmission to the relevant jurisdiction.
It was unanimously decided on 05/03/2018.