
Council of State, 15th Chamber Presidency
Case No: 2014/331
Decision No: 2017/65
Summary of the Request: The lawsuit was filed seeking compensation for the 15,148.00 TL damages paid by the plaintiff to the insured company, resulting from a traffic accident on January 20, 2009, involving the tractor with license plate 31 K 0362, insured by the plaintiff company with a comprehensive insurance policy. The accident occurred when the driver lost control of the vehicle due to hidden ice and slippery road conditions while traveling from Fethiye to Korkuteli. The plaintiff requested compensation for this damage, along with the highest advance interest rate applied by the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey to short-term loans, effective from March 20, 2009. As a result of this lawsuit, the Antalya 2nd Administrative Court ruled as follows: The appellant argues that the decision to dismiss the case on the grounds that the administration was not at fault according to the expert examination conducted by the Forensic Medicine Institute is unlawful and requests its reversal through appeal.
Summary of the Defense: It is argued that the appeal should be rejected.
Opinion: It is believed that the appeal should be rejected.
ON BEHALF OF THE TURKISH NATION
The Fifteenth Chamber of the Council of State, having heard the explanations of the examining judge and reviewed the documents in the file, considered the matter as follows:
Article 49, paragraph 2 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, titled “Reversal of the Decision,” stipulates that the Council of State may reverse a decision under review on appeal for the following reasons: a) The case was handled outside the scope of its duties and authority, b) An unlawful decision was rendered, c) There were errors or deficiencies in the application of procedural rules that could affect the decision. Upon examination of the documents in the file and the claims in the appeal petition, it has been concluded that the decision subject to appeal is in accordance with the law and procedure, and that there is no legal reason requiring the reversal of the decision.
For the reasons explained above; the appeal request is rejected, the decision of the Antalya 2nd Administrative Court dated 20/09/2010 and numbered E:2009/815, K:2010/967 is UPHELD, the file is sent to the Court, and in accordance with the first paragraph of Article 8 and the first paragraph of Article 54 of Law No. 2577, added by Law No. 6545 dated 18.06.2014, the right to request a correction of the decision is open within fifteen days from the day following the date of notification of this decision, unanimously decided on 10/01/2017.