Anasayfa » Blog » Recovery Of Erroneous Payment – Unjust Enrichment: Supreme Court Decision

Recovery Of Erroneous Payment – Unjust Enrichment: Supreme Court Decision

Request For Correction Of Gender Registration

Republic of Turkey

SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

3rd CIVIL CHAMBER

E. 2011/12926

K. 2011/18158

T. 21.11.2011

• ERRONEOUSLY PAID AUDIT COMPENSATION (Collection from the Defendant with Interest and Expenses – The Decision Will Be Made Based on the Report to be Obtained by an Expert to Investigate the Amount the Plaintiff is Entitled to Receive Due to the Overpayment Made to the Defendant)

• CLAIM FOR COLLECTION OF OVERPAYMENT (Erroneously Paid Audit Compensation – The Decision Will Be Made Based on the Report to be Obtained by an Expert to Investigate the Amount the Plaintiff is Entitled to Receive Due to the Overpayment Made to the Defendant)

• ERRONEOUS PAYMENT NOT BASED ON CONDITIONAL DISPOSITION (Without Discussing Whether it Can Be Claimed Within the Framework of the Rules of Unjust Enrichment in the Law of Obligations) The Decision to Dismiss the Case Requires Reversal – Recovery of Erroneously Paid Audit Compensation)

• EXPERT EXAMINATION (Recovery of Erroneously Paid Audit Compensation – The Amount the Plaintiff is Entitled to Receive Due to Overpayment Made to the Defendant by an Expert and the Decision Should Be Made Based on the Report)

818/m.61,62

 

SUMMARY: In the lawsuit petition, the recovery of the erroneously paid audit compensation, along with interest and expenses, from the defendant is requested. It has been explained that purely erroneous payments not based on any conditional provision can be reclaimed by the administration according to the unjust enrichment rules of the Turkish Civil Code. In this case, the court should investigate the amount the plaintiff is entitled to receive due to the overpayment made to the defendant by an expert and make a decision based on the report. The decision to dismiss the case without discussing whether a purely erroneous payment, not based on any conditional savings, could be claimed under the unjust enrichment rules of the Law of Obligations, necessitates reversal.

 

CASE: In the lawsuit, the plaintiff requested the recovery of 3,435.18 TL in erroneously paid audit compensation, along with interest and costs, from the defendant. The court dismissed the case, and the judgment was appealed by the plaintiff’s attorney.

 

CASE: After determining that the appeal request was filed within the time limit, all the documents in the file were read and considered:

 

DECISION: The plaintiff’s attorney, in the lawsuit petition, requested that the defendant be ordered to pay the 3,435.18 TL audit compensation, which was paid to the defendant who worked under contract at the Turkish Statistical Institute with expert and assistant expert positions, between January 20, 2006 and February 15, 2009, with legal interest to be calculated from the payment dates, even though it was not possible to pay audit compensation according to the Council of Ministers’ decision.

 

The defendant’s attorney argued that the payments were made to his client without a request, that the lawsuit filed after the 60-day period for filing a lawsuit had expired was unfounded, and requested that the lawsuit be dismissed.

The court dismissed the case on the grounds that it was filed after the 60-day statute of limitations had expired, and the plaintiff’s attorney appealed the decision.

 

As a rule, according to Article 62 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, a person who voluntarily pays something that is not owed can request a refund if they prove they made a mistake. The mistake mentioned in this article relates to performance and is an error indicating that the person making the payment did not have the intention or desire to make a donation. In other words, it means that if the plaintiff administration had not made a mistake, it would not have made the payment to the defendant.

 

The Supreme Court of Appeals, in its decision dated December 5, 1984, numbered 1982/13-387 E – 1984/997 K, clarified that purely erroneous payments not based on any conditional disposition can be reclaimed by the administration according to the unjust enrichment rules of the Turkish Code of Obligations. In this case, the court should investigate the amount the plaintiff is entitled to receive due to the overpayment made to the defendant through an expert witness and make a decision based on the report obtained.

 

The decision to dismiss the case with a written justification, without discussing whether a purely erroneous payment, not based on any conditional savings, can be claimed under the rules of unjust enrichment in the Law of Obligations, necessitates reversal.

 

CONCLUSION: Therefore, the judgment rendered without considering the principles explained above is incorrect, and the appeals are justified for these reasons. The judgment is REVERSED pursuant to Article 428 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the advance appeal fee shall be returned to the appellant upon request. The decision was made unanimously on November 21, 2011.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir