Anasayfa » Blog » Can A Lawsuit Be Filed For Material And Moral Damages To Settle Damages Caused By The Doctor’s And Private Hospital’s Negligence During Diagnosis And Treatment? Supreme Court Decision

Can A Lawsuit Be Filed For Material And Moral Damages To Settle Damages Caused By The Doctor’s And Private Hospital’s Negligence During Diagnosis And Treatment? Supreme Court Decision

REPUBLIC OF TURKEY SUPREME COURT

 

13th Civil Chamber

Case No: 2013/26332

Decision No: 2014/5046

Decision Date: 25.02.2014

 

COMPENSATION CASE – DAMAGES CAUSED BY THE DOCTOR AND PRIVATE HOSPITAL’S NEGLIGENCE DURING DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT – WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE AND WHAT WAS DONE – OBTAINING A REPORT SUITABLE FOR SUPREME COURT REVIEW AND JUDGING ACCORDING TO ITS RESULTS

 

SUMMARY: The case concerns the plaintiff’s claim for compensation for damages caused by the negligence of the defendant doctor and private hospital during diagnosis and treatment. In this case, the court should have obtained a report from a panel of expert witnesses specializing in ophthalmology, selected from the relevant departments of universities. This report would comprehensively evaluate the defendants’ legal positions and responsibilities, considering the evidence in the file. It would also explain what interventions and procedures were necessary, and whether the defendants should be held liable according to medical principles and regulations, providing reasons for this assessment. The report should be subject to review by the parties, the court, and the Court of Cassation. The court’s failure to consider this aspect and its subsequent judgment are contrary to procedural rules and law, and warrant reversal.

 

(The final decision is a directive.) (Articles 321, 386, 387, 388, 390, 394 of the Civil Code No. 818) (Article 4 of the Civil Code No. 4721) (Article 240 of the Civil Code No. 1086)

 

Case: Following the trial of the lawsuit for material and moral damages between the parties, the judgment rejecting the case for the reasons stated in the ruling was appealed by the plaintiff’s lawyer within the prescribed time limit. The file was examined, and the matter was discussed and considered.

 

Decision: The plaintiff claims that she has a congenital eye disorder, that she sought treatment at the defendant hospital for cataracts, that she underwent surgery performed by the other defendant doctor, and that she was discharged after necessary dressing changes. However, she alleges that her condition worsened after the surgery, that the defendants failed to fulfill their obligations regarding the treatment, that the surgery was faulty, resulting in irreversible damage to her right eye, causing significant psychological and social distress, and that she suffered material and moral losses due to the incorrect treatment. Therefore, reserving her right to claim further damages, she requests and sues for a total of 275,000.00 TL in compensation from the defendants, consisting of 250,000.00 TL in material damages and 25,000.00 TL in moral damages.

 

The defendants requested the dismissal of the case.

 

The court, based on the Forensic Medicine Institute report and stating that the procedures performed were in accordance with medical standards and that no medical error occurred, dismissed the case; the plaintiff appealed the judgment.

 

1- The lawsuit concerns the plaintiff’s claim for compensation for damages resulting from the negligence of the defendant doctor and private hospital during the diagnosis and treatment of the plaintiff. The basis of the lawsuit is an agency contract, and it is based on a breach of the duty of care (Articles 386-390 of the Turkish Code of Obligations). While an agent is not liable for the failure to achieve the intended outcome in the performance of the agency, they are liable for damages arising from the lack of diligence in their efforts, actions, and conduct in achieving that outcome. The agent’s liability is generally subject to the rules regarding the liability of an employee. Like an employee, the agent is obliged to act with diligence and is liable even for the slightest negligence (Article 321/1 of the Turkish Code of Obligations). Therefore, all negligence of the doctor and hospital within their professional field, even minor ones, should be considered an element of liability.

 

The agent is obliged to fulfill all professional requirements to prevent harm to the patient, to determine the patient’s medical condition promptly and without delay, to take all necessary precautions according to the specific situation, and to determine and apply appropriate treatment without delay. Even in situations that give rise to the slightest doubt, the attorney is obligated to conduct research to eliminate that doubt and, in the meantime, to take protective measures. When choosing among various treatment methods, the characteristics of the patient and the disease must be considered, attitudes and behaviors that would put the patient at risk must be avoided, and the safest course of action must be chosen. Indeed, the client (patient) has the right to expect meticulous care and attention from the attorney performing a professional task at all stages of treatment. An attorney who fails to demonstrate the necessary care should be considered to have failed to properly perform their agency, in accordance with Article 394/1 of the Turkish Code of Obligations.

 

In the specific case, the plaintiff; The plaintiff stated that he had a congenital eye disorder and that his right eye had further impaired vision due to cataracts; that he underwent surgery at the defendant hospital by the other defendant doctor on February 18, 2010; that he was discharged after the surgery, but on the same day, he experienced intense pain and discharge in his right eye, prompting him to consult the defendant doctor again, who then dressed his eye; and that due to the defendants’ negligence, his right eye suffered irreversible damage, and therefore demanded material and moral compensation.The defendant hospital argued that it had fulfilled its obligations completely, that there was no causal link between the plaintiff’s illness and the treatment received, and that the plaintiff’s claims were unfounded, requesting that the unjust and baseless lawsuit be dismissed. The other defendant doctor stated that there was no fault attributable to him, that he had fulfilled the requirements of his duty, and that the plaintiff’s claim for material and moral damages was unjust and excessive, requesting that the unjust and baseless lawsuit be dismissed. The court, basing its decision on the Forensic Medicine 3rd Specialization Board report dated 16/12/2011 and numbered 9296, decided to dismiss the lawsuit. In the said report; The report states that the posterior subcapsular cataract surgery performed by the defendants was in accordance with medical and scientific principles; that the plaintiff’s discomfort, as understood from the doctor’s statement in the file, was due to the patient pressing on the operated eye, causing corneal erosion (collapse) and the possibility of leakage due to the surgical wound; that the incision sites were sutured due to the patient’s actions; that this situation could have occurred as a result of the patient’s actions; and that the suturing procedure to prevent wound leakage after this stage was also in accordance with medical and scientific principles; and that the defendant doctor is not attributable to any fault for the cataract surgery performed and the subsequent wound leakage repair procedures performed by another physician.

 

As stated in the report on which the decision is based, while the plaintiff claims that this complication occurred because he pressed on his operated eye, the plaintiff has objections regarding this matter. In this context, the expert report must address and clarify the objections of both parties. The judge must also verify whether the expert opinion is consistent with the case file (Article 4 of the Turkish Civil Code, Article 240 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Our Chamber’s established practices and precedents are also in this direction. For the reasons explained, the Forensic Medicine Institute report is insufficient and cannot be used as a basis for the judgment. In this case, the court should obtain a report from a panel of expert witnesses specializing in ophthalmology, selected from the relevant departments of universities, which would comprehensively evaluate the defendants’ legal position and responsibilities, together with the evidence in the file, and explain what should have been done, what interventions and procedures were performed, and whether fault can be attributed to the defendants according to the requirements and rules of medicine, with reasons, and which is suitable for review by the parties, the court, and the Court of Cassation. The court’s failure to consider this aspect and its rendering of a judgment in writing is contrary to procedure and law. This necessitates reversal.

 

2- In light of the grounds for reversal, it is deemed unnecessary to examine the plaintiff’s other appeals at this time.

 

Conclusion: For the reasons explained in the first paragraph above, the decision is REVERSED in favor of the plaintiff; for the reasons explained in the second paragraph, there is no need to examine the plaintiff’s other appeals at this time. The decision was made unanimously on February 25, 2014.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir