Anasayfa » Blog » The Debtor’s Signed Or Blank Promissory Note Coming Into The Hands Of His Divorced Spouse, Resulting In Enforcement Proceedings Against The Debtor.

The Debtor’s Signed Or Blank Promissory Note Coming Into The Hands Of His Divorced Spouse, Resulting In Enforcement Proceedings Against The Debtor.

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKIYE

COURT OF CASSATION

GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF CIVIL CHAMBERS

BASIS NO: 2017/19-897

 

DECISION NO: 2018/464

 

DECISION DATE: 14.03.2018

 

>> THE DISPUTE REGARDING WHETHER THE DEBTOR’S CLAIM—THAT A SECURITY BOND SIGNED IN BLANK AND GIVEN TO A SECOND PARTY WAS SEIZED BY THE DEBTOR’S DIVORCED SPOUSE WHO THEN INITIATED EXECUTION PROCEEDINGS—SHALL BE CONSIDERED WITHIN THE SCOPE OF “DECEPTION” (FRAUD) AND WHETHER WITNESS TESTIMONY MAY BE RELIED UPON AS A MEANS OF PROOF BASED ON THE OUTCOME OF THIS DETERMINATION.

 

SUMMARY: The claim of the plaintiff debtor that “the promissory note was issued and delivered to constitute security for another commercial relationship; however, upon the non-acceptance of this security by the relevant party, the defendant seized the note, filled in the blanks in their own favor, and initiated enforcement” does not fit the definition of “deception” (fraud), and witness testimony cannot be relied upon regarding this claim.

 

Considering the theory of contract and the principle of trust, the allegation that the defendant filled out a blank note—entrusted to them for one reason or another—in violation of the agreement between the parties can only be proven by written evidence.

 

The decision for the “Suspension of the Pronouncement of the Judgment” (HAGB) rendered in the criminal case filed against the defendant for the crime of forgery of official documents shall not be deemed a conviction and is not binding upon the civil judge. The local court’s evaluation of the allegations as “deception” and its subsequent reliance on witness testimony to render a decision were improper.

 

GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF CIVIL CHAMBERS DECISION

Upon examination by the General Assembly of Civil Chambers, it was understood that the decision of resistance was appealed within the statutory period, and after reading the documents in the file, the necessity was discussed:

 

The lawsuit pertains to the request for a determination that the plaintiff is not indebted based on a promissory note (bono) alleged to have been seized through a criminal act and signed in blank.

 

The dispute brought before the General Assembly of Civil Chambers by way of resistance focuses on: whether the claims of the plaintiff shall be accepted within the scope of “deception” (fraud) in the context of the concrete case, and whether witness testimony may be relied upon as a means of proof based on the conclusion to be reached therein.

 

When the concrete case is evaluated within the framework of the aforementioned legal regulations and principles:

 

The claim of the plaintiff side is that the promissory note was issued and delivered to constitute security for another commercial relationship; however, upon the non-acceptance of this security by the relevant party, the defendant seized the note, filled in the blanks in their own favor, and initiated enforcement. This allegation does not constitute an act of the defendant intentionally creating a false conviction in the plaintiff regarding the issuance of the note, nor does it constitute the protection or maintenance of an existing false conviction; thus, it does not fit the definition of deception (fraud).

 

Since it is concluded that the plaintiff’s allegations cannot be accepted within the scope of deception, it is understood that witness testimony cannot be relied upon in the context of proving them. Considering the theory of contract and the principle of trust, the allegation that the defendant filled out a blank note—entrusted to them for one reason or another—in violation of the agreement between the parties can only be proven by written evidence (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 290; CCP Art. 201).

 

Although a public prosecution was initiated against the defendant at the Bursa 14th Criminal Court of First Instance for the crime of forgery of official documents, the decision rendered on 16.01.2014 resulted in the Suspension of the Pronouncement of the Judgment (HAGB). Since this decision is not deemed a conviction, it is not binding upon the civil judge.

 

Therefore, the court’s evaluation of the allegations as deception in a manner inconsistent with its legal definition, and its decision rendered by relying on witness testimony for its proof, as well as the decision of resistance formed on the same grounds, are not appropriate.

 

CONCLUSION: For the reasons written above, it was decided UNANIMOUSLY on 14.03.2018 to REVERSE the decision of resistance for the reasons shown in the reversal decision of the Special Chamber.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir