Anasayfa » Blog » In The Crime Of Loot, Is It Required To Get A Report From The Forensic Medicine Institute To Determine Whether The Text And Numbers Written On The Original Properties Of The Subject Properties Are The Witness’s Hands?

In The Crime Of Loot, Is It Required To Get A Report From The Forensic Medicine Institute To Determine Whether The Text And Numbers Written On The Original Properties Of The Subject Properties Are The Witness’s Hands?

Deed Registration Case Petition

REPUBLIC OF TÜRKİYE COURT OF CASSATION 6th Criminal Chamber

 

Basis No: 2014/14668

 

Decision No: 2018/761

 

Date: 15.01.2018

 

OFFENSE: Robbery (Yağma) – Requirement to obtain a report from the Council of Forensic Medicine (Adli Tıp Kurumu) to determine whether the text and figures on the original promissory notes were written by the witness – Reversal of the Judgment.

 

S U M M A R Y

In accordance with the statements provided by witness H.M.İ., a forensic report must be obtained from the Council of Forensic Medicine to verify whether the text and/or figures written on the original promissory notes—subject to the crime—are the handwriting products (el ürünü) of the said witness. This examination is necessary to allow for a proper judicial audit. Rendering a judgment based on an incomplete investigation (eksik soruşturma) without determining the legal status of defendant B.G. accordingly has necessitated the reversal of the judgment.

 

D E C I S I O N

The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants forced them to sign promissory notes totaling 12,000 TL at gunpoint. Conversely, the defendants and a witness (H.M.İ.) claimed that the notes were signed voluntarily to settle a debt and were actually filled out by the witness H.M.İ. himself prior to the alleged incident.

 

[Image showing the legal criteria for “Handwriting Analysis” (Grafolojik İnceleme) in criminal evidence]

 

Legal Analysis of the Reversal: In criminal law, the court is obliged to investigate the material truth. Since there is a direct contradiction between the plaintiffs’ claim of “forced signing” and the witness’s claim of “voluntarily filling out the notes,” the most objective way to resolve this is a graphological examination. If the Council of Forensic Medicine determines that the writing on the notes belongs to the witness—as he claimed—the plaintiffs’ allegation of robbery (that the notes were extorted at that specific moment) may be weakened. Failure to perform this technical examination constitutes an incomplete investigation.

 

CONCLUSION: The judgment is REVERSED (BOZULMASINA) unanimously on 15.01.2018.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir