Anasayfa » Blog » Can I Claim Damages For Moral Damages After A Mutual Divorce?

Can I Claim Damages For Moral Damages After A Mutual Divorce?

Eviction Of The Workplace Due To Necessity Supreme Court Decision

As is known, you can request moral damages during a divorce case, or even after the divorce case is concluded. However, if a request for moral damages was not made during the divorce case, you will need to file a separate lawsuit for it later. This lawsuit must be filed within one year of the divorce decree becoming final. Otherwise, your claim will be time-barred and will cause you harm.

 

In the case of an amicable divorce, the parties clearly and definitively agree on the financial and child-related consequences of the divorce in a protocol. According to the protocol prepared by the parties’ mutual consent, it is considered that they have finally resolved their dispute regarding the financial consequences of the divorce and liquidated their relationship. Therefore, moral damages cannot be claimed after the amicable divorce decree becomes final. The statement in the protocol that neither party has any claims for material or moral damages against the other will be binding on the parties in this regard.

 

Decision of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, dated October 20, 2014, numbered E. 2014/18709 and K. 2014/20286:

 

CASE: Following the trial of the case between the parties, the local court issued the judgment, the date and number of which are indicated above. The plaintiff (woman) appealed regarding the amount of moral damages and jewelry, court costs, and attorney’s fees; the defendant (husband) appealed regarding the determination of fault, jewelry, moral damages, and attorney’s fees. A hearing was requested for the appeal review. On May 27, 2014, the date set for the hearing, the attorney for the plaintiff E. K. U., who appealed with a hearing, appeared. The defendant E. K. and his attorney did not appear. After hearing the statement of the attending party, it was deemed appropriate to postpone the examination of the case and the rendering of a decision until after the hearing. Today, all the documents in the file were read, discussed, and considered:

 

DECISION: 1) The parties divorced by mutual agreement pursuant to Article 166/3 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, and the divorce decree became final on January 29, 2010. The claim for moral damages (Article 174/2 of the Turkish Civil Code) filed by the plaintiff woman on May 3, 2010, is based on the violence and ill-treatment she suffered from her husband while the marriage was ongoing. Since the divorce decree is based on the agreement of the parties, it is no longer possible for the plaintiff to claim moral damages after the divorce. If the parties have decided on a divorce by mutual agreement, it must be accepted that they have finally resolved their dispute regarding the financial consequences of the divorce and liquidated their relationship. Therefore, without considering that compensation for divorce can no longer be claimed after an amicable divorce, awarding moral damages (Article 174/2 of the Turkish Civil Code) in favor of the plaintiff is contrary to procedure and law and necessitates reversal.

 

2) The plaintiff requested the return of the jewelry in kind, or if return in kind is not possible, a ruling for its value. The court, without specifying what the jewelry consisted of and their individual values, ruled that “the defendant shall pay the plaintiff 18,819 TL, the equivalent of the value of the jewelry at the time of the lawsuit, along with legal interest accruing from the date of the decision.”

 

Article 297, paragraph (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 states that: in the concluding part of the judgment, without repeating any words from the reasoning, the obligations imposed on the parties and the rights granted to them with respect to each of the claims shall be listed under a numbered list; It is stipulated in the second paragraph of Article 298 of the same Law that the reasoned judgment cannot contradict the judgment announced, and that the judgment must be presented clearly and without causing any doubt or hesitation. According to this regulation, a judgment cannot be based on reference to any document such as the petition or expert report. Both in the judgment announced and recorded in the minutes, and in the reasoned judgment which must be prepared accordingly, the type, nature, quantity, and value of the goods subject to the judgment must be shown separately, and the obligation imposed on the parties and the right granted must be stated in a way that does not create difficulties in enforcement. Issuing a judgment in writing without considering this aspect is contrary to procedure and law.

 

CONCLUSION: The appealed judgment is REVERSED for the reasons stated in paragraphs 1 and 2 above. In accordance with the reason for reversal in paragraph 2, the appeals concerning the basis of the jewelry, attorney’s fees, and court costs are not examined. Similarly, in accordance with the reason for reversal in paragraph 1, the plaintiff’s appeal regarding the amount of compensation is not examined. The attorney’s fee of 1,100.00 TL awarded for the hearing shall be collected from the defendant and given to the plaintiff. The appeal filing fee shall be returned to those who paid it upon request. This decision was made unanimously on October 20, 2014, with the possibility of seeking a correction of the decision within 15 days from the date of notification.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir