
Family law, as regulated in Articles 118 and 201 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, applies to individuals who have established a marital bond through a civil marriage. However, due to the social structure, there are also individuals who have lived together for a long time through a religious marriage. Although those living together in this manner cannot benefit from rights such as jewelry or material/moral compensation under family law, they can assert these rights in civil courts.
The parties fulfill local traditions to get married and even hold a wedding ceremony, but they do not have a legal marriage. In this case, the civil status of the parties remains single. Considering the traditional structure of our society and the social environment in which the parties live, the fact that the parties live as husband and wife with the belief that a formal marriage will take place means that if these individuals separate, they will be labeled as widowed within society, making it difficult for them to remarry. Furthermore, the existence of such a situation may be used against them in any future marriages. For this reason, it is accepted that the parties have suffered harm and feel pain and sorrow, and an appropriate moral compensation is awarded with the aim of restoring the parties’ emotional balance, satisfying them emotionally, and preventing the party causing the harm from committing such an act again.
Indeed, the Supreme Court decisions also accept that those married under religious law can take their jewelry, that their material and moral compensation rights must be regulated, and that even in the event of the death of one of the parties, the other may claim compensation for loss of support where necessary. The difference here is that the alimony claim requested from the family court and other rights arising from family law are not granted to the religiously married spouse. At the same time, for these compensations, the parties must apply to the civil court of first instance, which has general jurisdiction, rather than the family court.
The Supreme Court’s decisions that could set a precedent on this issue are as follows:
According to the Supreme Court of Appeals 4th Civil Chamber’s decision dated 06.06.2016 and numbered 2016/170 E. and 2016/7430 K.; “1-) The case concerns the return of jewelry and a claim for moral damages. The local court dismissed the case, and the plaintiff appealed the decision.
The plaintiff claimed that she had married the defendant unofficially, had a wedding, that the defendant had deceived her with promises of marriage, that the defendant had started living with another woman, that her mental health had deteriorated due to these events, and that she was unable to take her gold jewelry and dowry items when she left the house, and requested the return of the jewelry and dowry items and compensation for the moral damage she suffered.
According to the statements and documents in the file, when the plaintiff left the home she shared with the defendant without a formal marriage, she had a number of jewelry items on her, and the defendant’s family wanted to take them, but she did not allow them to do so, and there were red marks on the plaintiff’s arm due to coercion. However, it was understood that there was no statement regarding the number and type of jewelry the plaintiff had on her when she left the house, and that the plaintiff’s petition did not explain how much gold was worn at the wedding and how much gold she had on her when she left the house.
The court should have made a decision by asking the plaintiff to explain the gold worn at the wedding and the gold she had on her when she left the house where she lived with the defendant, and by asking the witnesses to explain how much gold the plaintiff had on her when she left the house where she lived with the defendant. The decision to reject the claims for the return of the gold based on an incomplete investigation and written reasoning is contrary to procedure and law and requires reversal.
2-) Regarding the plaintiff’s appeal against the rejection of her claim for moral damages;
It is understood that the parties fulfilled local traditions to get married, got married at the wedding, only the official marriage was not performed, and the plaintiff and defendant are registered as single.
Considering the traditional structure of our society and the social environment in which the parties live, it is an inevitable fact that the plaintiff’s belief that a formal marriage would take place and her living with the defendant as husband and wife, being labeled as a widow in society, would make it difficult for her to remarry and that the existence of such a situation could be used against her in any future marriages. It should not be forgotten that it is an expected and necessary behavior model for the defendant, who shares the same social environment, to act more sensitively, considering the situation the plaintiff will find herself in.
Considering all these facts together, it must be accepted that the plaintiff was deceived by the defendant’s promise of marriage and suffered physical and psychological harm as a result, and experienced distress and sorrow. Therefore, in order to restore the plaintiff’s mental balance, provide emotional satisfaction, and deter the perpetrator from committing such an act again, it is necessary to award appropriate moral damages.
(The last sentence is a separate, unrelated statement and should be omitted from the translation as it is not part of the main text.) According to the ruling of the 17th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated November 25, 2015, numbered 2014/4811 E. and 2015/12693 K.; “The plaintiffs’ attorney stated that in the accident that occurred as a result of the collision between the van driven by M.A., who is not a party to the lawsuit, and the motorcycle driven and operated by F.Ö., who is not a party to the lawsuit, the plaintiff’s common-law wife, D.Ö., who was a passenger on the motorcycle, died; that the defendant vehicle driver was at fault in the accident; that the passenger was not at fault; and that the minor G. was born on June 20, 2010, shortly after the accident, and was born without a father, reserving the right to claim further damages; The plaintiff requested and sued for compensation for loss of support of 2,500.00 TL each for his common-law wife H. and daughter G., and for moral damages of 25,000.00 TL for his common-law wife H. and 20,000.00 TL for minor G., to be collected from the defendant with legal interest accruing from the date of the accident; during the trial, the plaintiff’s lawyer amended the claim for material damages to 103,146.16 TL for his common-law wife H. and 42,200.10 TL for child G., totaling 145,346.26 TL.
The defendant’s lawyer argued that the common-law wife had no right to claim material damages and that the claims for moral damages were excessive, requesting the dismissal of the case.
Based on the evidence gathered and the entire case file, the court ruled that the claim for material damages be partially accepted, awarding the defendant 80,000.00 TL for the plaintiff’s common-law wife Hülya and 45,200.10 TL for the minor G. as compensation for loss of support, with legal interest accruing from the date of the accident; and that the claim for moral damages be partially accepted, awarding the defendant 15,000.00 TL for the plaintiff’s common-law wife H. and 7,500.00 TL for the minor G. as compensation for moral damages, with legal interest accruing from the date of the accident. …”
According to the Supreme Court’s 4th Civil Chamber’s ruling dated April 14, 2016, numbered 2015/6000 E. and 2016/5100 K.: “The plaintiff stated that she and the defendant began living together with an Islamic marriage ceremony on June 8, 2009, that a child was born on June 23, 2010, that the child was acknowledged by the defendant, that they did not have a harmonious relationship, that she disrupted her life in Iğdır and came to Istanbul to marry the defendant, that the defendant deceived and stalled her with promises of a civil marriage, subjected her to all kinds of pressure and violence, expelled her from the house, and forced her to take her child and go to her sister’s house, claiming that her personal rights were violated, and requested that the defendant be held liable for moral damages.
The local court dismissed the case on the grounds that the plaintiff’s claims of being deceived with promises of a civil marriage and the violation of her personal rights could not be proven.”
According to the case file, after the death of his wife on March 15, 2009, the defendant was left alone with his three young children. Due to his father’s illness, he went to his hometown of Iğdır, where, upon his father’s advice, he decided to marry the plaintiff. He asked for her hand in marriage from her family, and with their approval, a henna night and religious marriage ceremony were held in Iğdır on June 8, 2009. Afterward, the defendant took the plaintiff to Istanbul, where he resided. They began living together in Istanbul, a situation that lasted approximately two years. On June 23, 2010, a child was born to them. The child was registered in the population registry by the defendant through recognition, but a civil marriage ceremony was not performed during this period. As a result, the plaintiff left the defendant’s side and began living with her sister.
According to the documents in the file, it is understood that the parties fulfilled the local traditions for marriage, got married with a wedding ceremony, but the civil marriage ceremony was not performed, and both the plaintiff and the defendant are registered as single.
Considering the traditional structure of our society and the social environment in which the parties live, the fact that the plaintiff lived as husband and wife with the defendant for two years under the belief that a formal marriage would take place, that the plaintiff, believing they would get married because of the promise of a formal marriage, was brought from Iğdır to Istanbul but the formal marriage did not take place for two years, that she was forced to live in her sister’s house with her child, and that she will carry the stigma of being a widow in society, will make it difficult for the plaintiff to remarry and that this situation may be used against her in future marriages. It should also not be forgotten that it is expected and necessary for the defendant, sharing the same social environment, to act more sensitively, taking into account the situation the plaintiff will find herself in.
Considering all these facts together, it must be accepted that the plaintiff was deceived by the defendant’s promise of marriage and suffered physical and psychological harm as a result, and experienced distress and sorrow. Therefore, in order to restore the plaintiff’s mental balance, provide emotional satisfaction, and deter the perpetrator from committing such an act again, it is necessary to award appropriate moral damages.
Considering the aspects explained above, the local court should have awarded an appropriate amount of moral damages in favor of the plaintiff, but its rejection of the claim is not in accordance with procedural rules and law; therefore, the decision must be overturned.”