Anasayfa » Blog » Does Monitoring a Female Employee in the Changing Room Give the Employer the Right to Terminate the Contract?

Does Monitoring a Female Employee in the Changing Room Give the Employer the Right to Terminate the Contract?

Deed Registration Case Petition

Article 25 of the Labor Law regulates the employer’s right to terminate the contract immediately for just cause. Accordingly, regardless of whether the contract is for a fixed term or not, the employer may terminate the employment contract before the end of the term or without waiting for the notice period in cases where the employee violates the rules of morality and good faith, such as sexual harassment. In such cases, the employee may be dismissed without payment of seniority and notice compensation. Examples of conduct that violates the rules of morality and good faith include: the employee deceiving the employer, words and behavior that violate honor and integrity, sexual harassment, verbal abuse and drunkenness, behavior that violates honesty and loyalty, committing a crime at the workplace, absenteeism, failure to perform duties, endangering work safety, damaging the employer’s property, etc.

Therefore, as seen in the Supreme Court decision example below, the employee’s contract was immediately terminated by the employer for just cause due to the employee spying on the female employees’ changing room and sexually harassing female employees. As a result of the immediate termination for just cause by the employer, the employee will not be entitled to seniority and notice compensation.

However, it is accepted that the employer does not need to hear the employee’s defense in order to exercise the right to immediate termination for just cause due to the employee’s behavior that violates the rules of morality and good faith. In this case, the employer terminates the employment contract by unilateral declaration of intent.

The employer’s right to terminate the contract based on conduct that violates the rules of morality and good faith cannot be exercised after 6 working days have passed from the date the other party learned that one of the parties engaged in such conduct, and in any case, after one year has passed since the act occurred.

However, if the employer has suffered any damage due to the employee’s conduct that is the subject of the termination, the employer may claim compensation from the employee in accordance with the general provisions pursuant to Article 26/2 of the Labor Law.

 

RELEVANT SUPREME COURT DECISION:

Supreme Court of Turkey, 7th Civil Chamber Case No: 2014/12153 Decision No: 2014/20578 Date: 10.11.2014
The defendant’s representative requested that the Supreme Court review the judgment rendered in the case between the parties, and it was determined that the appeal was filed within the time limit. The file was reviewed, and the necessary deliberations were made:

The plaintiff’s representative stated that their client worked at the defendant’s workplace between May 2002 and June 29, 2012, and that on June 28, 2012, during dinner hours, they were accused of “looking into the female employees’ changing room through the window.” 06.2012, that on 28.06.2012, during dinner hours, he was accused of “looking into the female employees’ changing room through the window,” and that upon his refusal to accept the accusation, he was dismissed without compensation. The plaintiff’s attorney requested that the defendant pay the seniority and notice compensation.
The defendant’s attorney stated that stated that the plaintiff had been working at the defendant’s workplace since May 1, 2002, and that the employment contract was terminated for just cause pursuant to Article 25/II (c) of the Labor Law due to “disruptive, offensive, and immoral behavior towards female employees at the workplace,” and defended the dismissal of the case.

The court ruled that “… and … identified the person they saw behind the fogged glass at the window from the side profile, and identified him from a scanned document taken in 2002 and pasted into Word in the office manager’s office … and that the dismissal of … was unjustified due to the employer’s failure to adequately separate the women’s and men’s changing rooms, toilets, and washrooms.”

There is a dispute between the parties as to whether the termination of the employment contract was based on just cause.

In this specific case, the plaintiff employee claimed that the employment contract was terminated without just cause, while the defendant employer argued that the employment contract was terminated for just cause.

In the specific case subject to termination, the defendant employer claimed that the plaintiff was watching the female changing room of employees ..and …. The plaintiff denied that such an incident had occurred. However, the employees named …and …, who filed the complaint, stated in their complaint to the employer and during the court inspection that the person watching the changing room was the plaintiff. There is no animosity between the plaintiff and the above-mentioned individuals who made these allegations against the plaintiff that would require them to make false accusations. The court’s decision to accept the claim with written justification is erroneous and requires reversal, as the action in question should have been deemed sexual harassment by the employee against another employee of the employer, leading to the termination of the employment contract by the employer for just cause and the rejection of the claims for seniority and notice compensation.

Therefore, the defendant’s attorney’s appeal objections aimed at these aspects should be accepted, and the decision should be overturned.

CONCLUSION: The appealed decision is OVERTURNED for the reasons stated above, and the advance appeal fee is to be refunded to the defendant upon request. This decision was made unanimously on November 10, 2014.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir