Anasayfa » Blog » Can Alimony and Compensation Be Awarded in Favor of the Woman Who Is More at Fault in the Divorce?

Can Alimony and Compensation Be Awarded in Favor of the Woman Who Is More at Fault in the Divorce?

In divorce proceedings, the parties may claim material and moral damages and alimony from each other in accordance with Articles 174 and 175 of the Turkish Civil Code. However, the law explicitly stipulates that for both material and moral damages claims and for alimony claims to be accepted, the claiming party must be less at fault or completely free of fault compared to the other party. Provisions regarding compensation and alimony that may be claimed in divorce proceedings are set out in Articles 174 and 175 of the Turkish Civil Code.

 

Article 174 of the Turkish Civil Code states:

“The party who is free from fault or less at fault, whose current or expected interests have been harmed due to the divorce, may request appropriate material compensation from the party at fault. The party whose personal rights have been violated due to the events leading to the divorce may request an appropriate amount of money as moral compensation from the other party at fault.”

 

and Article 175 of the Turkish Civil Code;

“The party who will fall into poverty due to the divorce may request alimony from the other party in proportion to their financial capacity for an indefinite period, provided that their fault is not more severe. The fault of the party obligated to pay alimony is not considered.”

As seen in the above provisions, the parties may request material and moral compensation as well as alimony for poverty in divorce cases. However, the law explicitly requires that the fault of the requesting party not be more severe for these claims to be accepted. In light of these provisions in the law, the Court of Cassation has also ruled that, for claims for material and moral damages and alimony to be accepted, the requesting party must be free of fault or less at fault.

 

Supreme Court of Appeals, 2nd Civil Chamber: In its ruling dated 23.06.2016, numbered 2016/11706 and K: 2016/12145;

“… 2- As explained in paragraph 1 above, the defendant woman is fully at fault for the events that led to the divorce. The conditions of Articles 174/1 and 2 of the Turkish Civil Code have been met in favor of the man. In this case, it is necessary to award appropriate amounts of material and moral compensation in favor of the plaintiff man, and the rejection of the request is not considered correct.

 

3- The party who will fall into poverty due to the divorce may request alimony from the other party in proportion to their financial capacity for an indefinite period, provided that their fault is not more severe. (TMK m. 175) Alimony for poverty cannot be awarded in favor of a woman who is entirely at fault. Therefore, the rejection of the woman’s request for poverty alimony was necessary, and its acceptance in writing was not considered correct.” According to this regulation, if, as a result of the trial in the divorce case, it is decided that the woman is more at fault than the man for the end of the marriage, the woman will not be able to receive material and moral compensation or poverty alimony.

In other words, in divorce cases, it is not a given that the woman will be awarded material and moral damages and alimony under all circumstances. During the proceedings, if the man proves that the woman is more at fault or entirely at fault for the divorce, it is determined by both the Court of Cassation decisions and Articles 174 and 175 of the Turkish Civil Code that no material or moral compensation or alimony will be awarded in favor of the woman.

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir