
Judicial Decisions Related to Rent Determination
Related Supreme Court Decisions
-The case is about the request for monthly rental money.case is the request for monthly rental money. The Supreme Court’s Decision on Unification of Practice No. 2/4 dated 18/11/1964, which determines the method of determining the rent money, also provides for the “reasonable and fair” detThe case is about the request for monthly rental money. The Supreme Court’s Decision on Unification of Practice No. 2/4 dated 18/11/1964, which determines the method of determining the rent money, also provides for the “reasonable and fair” determination of the rent money and its “limited increase”. Therefore, the determination of the rental price is a limitation, and the judge should take into account that it is a limitation when determining the rental price. In accordance with the Decision to Combine the Case Law in question and the principle of “right and nesafet” according to established Supreme Court practices, when the judge makes this limitation, first of all, if the parties have all the evidence, the original or approved examples of precedent lease agreements shelf precedents should be viewed and examined individually, so that the data obtained are embodied, separately with the place of the case (Location, environment, nature, mode of use, rental start date, rental periods, etc.In accordance with the Decision to Combine the Case Law in question and the principle of “right and nesafet” according to established Supreme Court practices, when the judge makes this limitation, first of all, if the parties have all the evidence, the original or approved examples of precedent lease agreements shelf precedents should be viewed and examined individually, so that the data obtained are embodied, separately with the place of the case (Location, environment, nature, mode of use, rental start date, rental periods, etc.) All the characteristics that affect the rental price should be compared, and the reasons why the comparable rental prices are or are not appropriate should be explained with concrete reasons. The rental income that the immovable property in question can bring if it is rented again should be determined, and the court should rule a reasonable rental income in accordance with justice and fairness, taking into account this rental income; especially the purposes that the parties expect from the rental contract. (Supreme Court 6thThe rental income that the immovable property in questioThe rental income that the immovable property in question can bring if it is rented again should be determined, and the court should rule a reasonable rental income in accordanche rental income that the immovable property in question can bring if it is rented again should be determined, and the court should rule a reasonable rental income in accordance with justice and fairness, taking into account this rental income; especially the purposes that the parties expect from the rental contract. (Supreme Court 6thHD. 2014/1986e. 11/03/2014 Date, Decision No. 2014/2823)
-Rental determination cases, which are within the scope of disputes arising from rental agreements, are also heard in civil courts of peace. (Supreme Court 3rd HD; 2012/19984 E. Decision No. 2012/26086)
-Since the rent money is requested to be determined through a lawsuit, even if the amount requested to be increased is paid, the lawsuit should not be rejected and a decision regarding the determination should be made. (Supreme Court 6th Civil Chamber; 2014/5706 E.Since the rent money is requested to be determined through a lawsuit, even if the amount requested to be increased is paid, the lawsuit should not be rejected and a decision regarding the determination should be made. (Supreme Court 6th Civil Chamber; 2014/5706 E. 12/06/2014 Date, Decision No. 2014/7831)
-The case for determining the rental price can be filed at any time in accordance with the Jurisprudential Unification Decision dated 21/11/1966 and numbered 19/10.The case for determining the rental price can be filed at any time in accordance with the Jurisprudential Unification Decision dated 21/11/1966 and numbered 19/10. The notification date of the notice sent regarding the increase of the rent money or the petition filed for the same purpose is important in terms of waiting for the period in which the rent money will be valid to be determined. As a rule, if there is an increase requirement in the lease agreement for future years, if the increase will has been notified to the tenant by notice or by filing a rent determination lawsuit and notifying the other party (15) days before the end of the term, he/she always has the right to file a rent lawsuit until the end of the term during the renewed period. a rule, if there is an increase requirement in the lease agreement for future years, if the increase will has been notified to the tenant by notice or by filing a rent determination lawsuit and notifying the other party (15) days before the end of the term, he/she always has the right to file a rent lawsuit until the end of the term during the renewed period. (Decision of the Court of Cassation to Unify the Case Law; Decision Dated 21/11/1966, Numbered 19-10)
-(Article 345 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098)(Article 345 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098) in accordance with the second paragraph of the article, if the lawsuit to determine the rental price is filed no later than thirty days before the start of the new period, or if it is filed by the end of the subsequent new rental period, provided that the lessor has given written notice to the lessee that the rental price will be increased during this period, the rental price to be determined by the court binArticle 345 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098) in accordance with the second paragraph of the article, if the lawsuit to determine the rental price is filed no later than thirty days before the start of the new period, or if it is filed by the end of the subsequent new rental period, provided that the lessor has given written notice to the lessee that the rental price will be increased during this period, the rental price to be determined by the court binds the lessee from the beginning of the new rental period. (Supreme Court 6. HD; 2014/7428 E. Decision No. 2015/508 Dated 21/01/2015)
-(Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098)(Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098) in accordance with the article, in lease agreements for a period longer than five years or renewed after five years, and at the end of each subsequent five years, the new lease price to be applied is determined by the judge in accordance with equity, taking into account the rate of increase in the producer price index, thArticle 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098) in accordance with the article, in lease agreements for a period longer than five years or renewed after five years, and at the end of each subsequent five years, the new lease price to be applied is determined by the judge in accordance with equity, taking into account the rate of increase in the producer price index, the situation of the leased and the precedent rental prices. (Supreme Court 6 HD.; 2015/2330 E . Decision No. 2015/3768)
-Considering that the tenant is a former tenant, it is necessary to determine the rental price in accordance with the rights and obligations by making a certain discount from the price determined by the expert witness board. (Supreme Court 6.HD; 2013/4407 E.Considering that the tenant is a former tenant, it is necessary to determine the rental price in accordance with the rights and obligations by making a certain discount from the price determined by the expert witness board. (Supreme Court 6.HD; 2013/4407 E. Decision Dated 07/11/2013 and Numbered 2013/15048)
-In the Decision to combine the Case Law of the Court of Cassation dated 18/11/1964 and 2/4, which determines the method of determining rent money, a “limited increase” is envisaged with the appreciation of rent money at a level “appropriate to rights and posafety”. For this reason, the determination of rent money is a limitation, and while the judge appreciates rent money, considering that it is a limitation, firstly, all the evidence of the parties, the precedent lease term contracts, if any, should be taken and viewed individually by the expert, and the party’s precedents should be compared separately with the place subject to litigation, its location, environment, nature, mode of use, face measurement, date of lease commencement, all the qualities that affect rent money, such as lease duration, should be explained with concrete reasons why the precedent lease prices are appropriate precedents or not, The rental income that the immovable property in question can bring if it is rented out again should be determined, and the court should decide on a reasonable rental income that is in line with justice and fairness and the purposes that the parties expect from the rental contract, taking into account this rental income. (Supreme Court 3rdhe rental income that the immovable property in question can b