17. Legal Department 2018/297 E. , 2018/4514 K.
“Text Of Jurisprudence”
COURT : District Court of Cassation
FIRST DEGREE
COURT : Commercial Court of First Instance
At the end of the trial of the compensation case between the parties; The District Court of Justice of the 8th … on the rejection of the case for reasons written in the decision8. Although the decision No. 2017/483 – 2017/732 issued by the Law Department was requested by the deputy plaintiff during the review period of the Supreme Court of 26.10.2017 Decision No. 732, the file was examined and considered necessary:
Decision
The deputy plaintiff; in his petition to the Insurance Arbitration Commission; On 25/10/2015 proxy numbered in the direction of the vehicle with the vehicle license plate … plate No. identified the driver as a result of the collision, defendant automobile insurance with the company who’s willing to substitute in treatments for individuals that belong to … the license plate of the damage, the insurance application for the removal of defendant denied due to the driver being intoxicated with a post dated 23/11/2015 during the event, the proxy only 1.29 blood alcohol in the body at the time of the accident was found, but as can be understood from the observations report the accident, the event did not happen with the influence of alcohol, In accordance with the established case law of the Supreme Court, the defendant … stated that his company must pay damages, and requested that a decision be made on the collection of TL 57,349.30 from the insurance company, provided that the rights to the excess are reserved.
… Insurance A.In his response, the deputy Ş; At the time of the accident, the driver claimed that the plaintiff had been determined to have drunk 1.29 promil and that there was no dispute about it, in this case the damage caused was outside the scope of insurance coverage, and asked for a decision to dismiss the case.
By the Arbitration Committee of the Insurance Arbitration Commission for Disputes; it was decided to reject the application, the plaintiff’s appeal to the Arbitration Panel of the Insurance Arbitration Commission for Appeals decided to accept the section on the power of attorney fee of the appeal, to reject other appeals; The appeal was appealed against the Decision of the Arbitration Panel by the applicant’s deputy within the time limit.
The plaintiff in the petition of appeal, the client driver during the accident due to the lack of alcohol in the causation of 1.29 PROMIL the accident, the insurance company should be responsible for the damage, in this aspect of settled case law of the Supreme Court, therefore, the appeal of the decision of the arbitration board stated that it is against the law and procedures.
Concrete in the review of Appeal in a case in which the compensation is desired zararlandirici 23/11/2015 of the date the incident occurred, to remain within the scope of insurance coverage that would decide whether there is a new regulation; during the event of the plaintiff so as to exceed the legal limit is outside the scope of insurance cover for damage due to being an alcoholic, it is clear that and, therefore, a denial of the arbitration board in deciding whether the case should be is not a direction that is contrary to law and procedures; the denial of the request for appeal on the ground that are not seen on the decision was made; judgment was appealed by the plaintiff’s attorney.
In the concrete event that the plaintiff-insured claims the vehicle damage from his own insurance, the general terms of the law and the october of the policy were incorrectly applied. A/1 of the General Conditions of Casco Insurance. according to the article, accidents such as being hit by a stationary or moving object or being allowed to hit such an object, overturning, falling, rolling as a result of sudden and external effects on the vehicle against the will of the insured or the driver of the vehicle while it is in motion or in a standstill 3. it is understood that the material damages caused by the burning of the vehicle, theft or attempted theft are covered by the coverage of this type of insurance. On the other hand, TTC.of 1409(1282 md.) in accordance with the article, the insurer is responsible for the risks incurred after the establishment of a valid insurance relationship, and as a rule, the claim that the risk is excluded from the coverage must be proved by the insurer. If the incident occurs not in the manner reported by the insured, but in the manner claimed by the insurer, the General Terms of this form of Casco Insurance A.5
it must be in the cases other than the collateral listed in the article. In addition, A of the General Conditions of Motor Vehicle Casco Insurance.5.5. in the article; It is stated that the damages caused during the use of the vehicle by people who have taken drugs or drinks more than the amount prohibited under the Road Traffic Law are outside the insurance coverage. In order for the damage to be unsecured, the driver must have been in an accident under the influence of alcohol only (exclusively) in accordance with the way the accident occurred. In other words, the fact that the driver is drunk alone does not require that the damage be unsecured. Moreover, in such a situation, the burden of proving that the damage is unsecured falls on the insurer.
In the concrete case, the insured in the traffic accident that occurred was found to have 1.29 promil alcohol. In the accident detection report, it is stated that the entire defect is on the opposing vehicle driver. In the Ekper report, it is also explained that the 100% defect is on the opposite side. Since the court did not investigate the defect either, it was not considered correct to decide to dismiss the case by considering the risk as unsecured due to the fact that the insured person who did not have any defects in the incident was drunk.
CONCLUSION: For the reasons described above, HMK 373/2 No. 6100 may be applied to the VIOLATION of the provision by accepting the appeals of the plaintiff’s deputy for the reasons described above. in accordance with the article, it was unanimously decided on 25/04/2018 to send the file to the District Court (an example of a decision to the arbitration panel), to return the fee received in advance to the appellant on request, to the plaintiff.